advertisement

Friday, October 23, 2009

What Do Factfinders Hear Expert Witnesses Say?

When an expert speaks, what does the jury hear?
In an article published in the October 2009 edition of the journal Law and Human Behavior, researchers Dawn McQuiston-Surrett and Michael J. Saks examined "how variations in the presentation of forensic science information affect factfinders' judgments in a trial." Essentially, they looked at jurors' and judges' responses to expert testimony about matching a hair found at the scene of a murder with hair from the defendant.

Overall, as might be expected, jurors placed more emphasis on the expert testimony and used it in their verdict of guilt than judges did.

However, both judges and jurors were more impressed with expert testimony that had a strong "qualitative" feel to it. For example, if the expert said the hair "matched" the defendant or was "similar in all microscopic characteristics," judges and jurors gave that testimony a lot of weight. They gave less weight to expert testimony stating the defendant's hair was "similar to the hair found at the murder scene, although there are a number of people in the community whose hair would also have the same identifying attributes." The "match" or "similar in all microscopic characteristics" testimony sounds much more confident than the "other people have the same microscopic characteristics" approach.

So, what do you do with this information? I suppose the prosecution might want to talk to their expert about asserting their opinions in qualitative, confident ways (without distorting the truth, of course). The defense will want the expert to then discuss the limits of the forensic testing used in cross examination.

Warning for the defense: This same research study found that having experts talk about the limits of testing did not affect jurors' opinions all that much.

Warning for the prosecution: If the defendant opts for a bench trial, this study found that judges do not let the "match" or "similar in all microscopic characteristics" testimony affect their estimation of guilt as nearly as much as jurors do.

Thanks for reading-- Maximillian Wachtel, Ph.D.
CherryCreekPsychology.com
Facebook.com/drmaxwachtel
Twitter.com/mwachtel

reference:


McQuiston-Surrett, D., Saks, M. J. (2009). The testimony of forensic identification science: What expert witnesses say and what factfinders hear. Law and Human Behavior, 33(5), 436-453, doi:10.1007/s10979-008-9169-1

50 comments:

Rush for men is a spicy-woods perfume which can replica watches uk be regarded as the progenitor of cedary pen shavings-dry incense. Eat note is the cedarwood, which is nothing short of classy. It is well-handled with an increase of wood layers on it, which are the fragrance ballsy. The top note is sweet lavender. The sweet lavender quality quickly makes over into the spicy-woody heart of the arrangement with sandalwood, cedar, incense, Okouma tree. The long trek is rolex replica composed of patchouli, sandalwood, white musk. Fashionistas love the new version of these bags. The ones used for luxury and travel are large. You must remember that these are not made of materials like jute and straw. Designers have ascertained that the material is in a way that the bag has a great look and a texture. Rough usage is not recommended. Totes watches have been a replica watches uk great addition to any woman’s wardrobe. All of us want to be trendy and stylish. The mini version of these bags aids in fulfilling this wish. In spite of their size, they offer adequate space. Their look is in a way that it spells out elegance. The skill in the design of hublot replica uk these bags is significant. On the shallow level, it looks microscopic. But, if you expert inside you will be amazed at the space.

This is such a cool blog, atleast content has a meaning unlike those useless blogs on the internet. Independence Day Information in Marathi

Thanks for this great post. Download nova launcher app from: nova launcher prime apk

Nice point of you. would like to hear more from this platform. thanks download ludo king

This comment has been removed by the author.

This is really awesome, am so glad to read this informative article. I must confess this one of the exceptional blog that I have ever come across. Keep sharing this kind of information to users.

I'm a freelancer by profession, I can help you write a blog post on any nich, incase you may need a professional writing service, here are some of my articles:
Quick tips on Email marketing tips,
Best free music download sites get high quality mp3 audios,
Download AnonyTun Pro Apk best free vpn for Android,
Best places to Watch Hindi movies online free,
Best 17 GameCube ROMS for Dolphin Emulator,
A professional tips on How to write a cover letter,
Ultimate guide to Human resource management,
Best websites to download free movie,
Abokifx today's Black market Naira to Dollar exchange rate,
Best working iptv m3u playlist url to watch live iPTV channels free on Kodi and Roku
.
Do you need my service?

I'd like to thank you for the efforts you have put in writing this blog. I'm hoping to check out the same high-grade blog posts by you in the future as well. movie box



Thanks for sharing this wonderful article. pondok promosis

Thanks for sharing this wonderful post. It would be really helpful. ps2 bios. opera mini apk mod. nts jobs Really appreciate it.

You can hear but not more than powerful than birds. and play clash royale mod apk latest version game.

Very amazing post. It would be really handy to use. Health Insurance Quotes


Thanks for sharing this wonderful article. <a href="https://templicate.com/> resume templates with shapes </a>

Nice Post. Thanks for sharing information about it. List of drug rehabs

Great Information sharing. Thank you very much for this great post. Submit Articles Online For Free

Amazing your content. Thank you for sharing. How to create www.gmail.com account? You want to create gmail account? Visit this website https://teachnow.xyz/gmail-login/

Amazing your content. I did a invisalign treatment , and it has moved quite a bit before finding its final form Emmanuelle from Orthodontie Paris

Amazing Aticle. Thank you for sharing. Military intelligence is responsible for all collected intelligence during Army missions.

I Really Like your blog. Thanks for sharing. is elanlari

It should be noted that whilst ordering papers for sale at paper writing service, you can get unkind attitude. In case you feel that the bureau is trying to cheat you, don't buy term paper from it. Skincare junkie

I have bookmarked your website because this site contains valuable information in it. I am really happy with articles quality and presentation. Thanks a lot for keeping great stuff. I am very much thankful for this site. If you need instagram followers you can buy instagram followers

Post a Comment

Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More