advertisement

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

What Evidence Can Expert Witnesses Use?


In 1923, the U.S. Supreme Court decided the landmark case of Frye v. United States. In that case, attorneys were attempting to enter into evidence information from a polygraph test. The Court ruled that scientific evidence can be admissible if it has "gained general acceptance in the particular field to which it belongs." This is sometimes referred to as the "general acceptance" standard.

The Frye decision held until 1993, at which point the U.S. Supreme Court heard Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals. In this case, the Court unanimously ruled that scientific evidence can only be admissible if it meets the following criteria:

  1. It must be subject to empirical testing: the theory or technique must be falsifiable, refutable, and testable.
  2. It must be subjected to peer review and publication.
  3. It must have a known potential error rate.
  4. The existence and maintenance of standards and controls concerning its operation must be in place.
  5. It must, to some degree, conform to theory and technique that is generally accepted by a relevant scientific community.
In 1999, the U.S. Supreme Court further refined its ruling on admissibility of expert testimony. In Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael, the Court ruled that the Daubert ruling applies to the three types of knowledge mentioned in Rule 702 (Federal Rules of Evidence), scientific, specialized and technical. Psychological evidence is covered under Daubert.

It is interesting to note that, due to a 1998 ruling in United States v. Sheffer, the Court found that procedures that appear to be valid and reliable must be closely scrutinized using the Daubert standard. Most courts do not consider psychological expert testimony that involves only clinical/medical judgment (i.e., it does not involve tests or assessment procedures) to be subject to the Daubert standard. However, if a psychologist uses tests or assessment procedures that give the appearance of "infallibility," then that testimony's admissibility hinges on whether the procedures meet the Daubert standard.

So, what does this mean? Essentially, a psychologist or psychiatrist can say whatever he/she wants to about a particular case, and it can be entered into evidence as long as that testimony is only based only on the professional's clinical/medical judgment (even if that judgment is absolutely incorrect). As soon as a professional starts using tests and procedures that increase the accuracy of clinical/medical opinions, his/her testimony must be held to a higher standard.

NOTE: The standards I discussed above apply to federal cases only. Many states have adopted similar standards, and are often referred to as "Frye states" or "Daubert states." In Colorado, the decision in People v. Shreck (2001) dictates the following: "Under the standard established in this rule [Rule 702, Colorado Court Rules of Evidence, Testimony By Experts], the trial should focus on the reliability and relevance of the scientific evidence and determine the reliability of the scientific principles, the qualifications of the witness, and the usefulness of the testimony to the jury. In determining the reliability and relevance of the evidence, the court should apply a broad inquiry and consider the totality of the circumstances in each specific case, considering a wide range of factors. Because the applicable standard is so liberal, the court should also apply its discretionary authority under C.R.E. 403 to ensure the probative value of the evidence is not substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice."

In my experience, the Shreck standard allows for the vast majority of the data a psychologist or psychiatrist could produce (no matter the quality of the data) to be entered into evidence.

Thanks for reading-- Max Wachtel, Ph.D.
www.CherryCreekPsychology.com


@mwachtel
Facebook.com/drmaxwachtel

26 comments:

Among the better seems result from people, for instance superstar Kate Moss, that have a single flaw inside their seem, for instance sloppy hublot replica uk, a chunk which is not entirely buttoned, or perhaps shoes or boots that do not necessarily match up. If the rolex replica sale is normally frizzy, work with a moisturizing shampoo and also conditioner. The particular cuticles of one's head of hair will probably be safeguarded coming from wetness by way of a level developed through the program. Additionally it is best if you maneuver far from something in which claims it really is "volumizing". If you utilize tubes regarding hublot replica uk, make an effort to refrain from yanking the particular wand out there and also inside regarding the conduit. That simply will serve to be able to capture oxygen inside jar. This can raise the potential for bacterial progress. To be able to carefully coating the particular remember to brush, weaken the particular cover and also test content spinning the particular applicator remember to brush to the left and also proper inside conduit just before eliminating hublot replica uk entirely regarding program.

It is now and again said that there is never a 'cop' around when you require one; the same can likewise be said of cash. Therefore, there is an industry committed to giving trade advances to individuals out need,Cash Advances San diego

movers and packers in Nallagandla - Hyderabad is the most rising business entity in movers and packersdomain with personal branches and associates in India. movers and packersin Nallagandla - Hyderabad is one of the recognized names in this industry. movers and packersin Nallagandla - Hyderabad offer services right from taking up parcels from your door step to supplying it at the desired locations, including dealing with all associates issues, like sales, taxes and insurance etc.
Movers and Packers in Nallagandla

movers and packers offers wide selection of moving services in Banjara Hills Kondapur space. we have a tendency to are native movers and packers Banjara Hills providing house moving, business relocation, vehicle transportation, storage and packing services. we've nineteen years of expertise in providing packers and movers services and may handle move of any kind. whether or not you would like to maneuver regionally in Banjara Hills space, to the other location in Kondapur, to the other town in India or internationally, we will give excellent moving solutions at terribly competitive value.
movers and packers in Banjara hills

Packers and Movers in CHANDANAGAR Hyderabad offers fullPackers and Movers in services like Relocation services, Packing and moving, office relocation, home shifting, apartment relocation, storage ,furniture moving, HouseholdPackers and Movers in ,, house shifting transport Hyderabad, local house shifting Hyderabad, domestic moving, home relocation, car transportation, Local moving, transportation of household;d goods from a place to another. We are topPackers and Movers in CHANDANAGAR as we know inch by inch in Chandanagar.
Packers and Movers in Chanda Nagar

We provide features to track your goods in real time and also ask for timely updates from us about movers and packers in Jubilee Hills. Customers can go through dispatch details and check the movement of their belongings, pickup timings. You can contact us regarding any help in the tracking of your goods. Expect quality service for us and make your shifting experience a happy one. Happy moving and we hope to serve you soon!
movers and packers in Jubilee Hills

movers and packers in - Kondapur is the perceptible service provider of packaging and relocation of commercial and household goods from one place to another place with absolute security and trustworthiness.
movers and packers in Kondapur

Now a day’s shifting from one place to another is became very hectic and tedious job. But in your area it is just like to get cream from milk; Packers and Movers in Kukatpally - Hyderabad is there to help each and every point.
Packers and Movers in Kukatpally

Are you living in Madhapur and looking for relocating from Madhapur to any other area within Kondapur? Packing and Moving within city looks easy task in the first look. However, if you have experienced it earlier, you will have a different idea! Relocating within the same city is as stressfull as relocating to another city. movers and packers Madhapur make your moving as simple as possible. You can sit back and relax while our expert moving and packing assistants can help you do the job.
movers and packers in Madhapur

best packers and movers in Nallagandla....we are providing best packing and moving service.
Packers and Movers in Nallagandla

packers and movers offers wide selection of moving services in Banjara Hills Kondapur space. we have a tendency to are native packers and movers Banjara Hills providing house moving, business relocation, vehicle transportation, storage and packing services. we've nineteen years of expertise in providing packers and movers services and may handle move of any kind. whether or not you would like to maneuver regionally in Banjara Hills space, to the other location in Kondapur, to the other town in India or internationally, we will give excellent moving solutions at terribly competitive value.
packers and movers in Banjara hills

Movers and Packers in CHANDANAGAR Hyderabad offers fullMovers and Packers in services like Relocation services, Packing and moving, office relocation, home shifting, apartment relocation, storage ,furniture moving, HouseholdMovers and Packers in , house shifting transport Hyderabad, local house shifting Hyderabad, domestic moving, home relocation, car transportation, Local moving, transportation of household;d goods from a place to another. We are topMovers and Packers in CHANDANAGAR as we know inch by inch in Chandanagar.
Packers and Movers in Chanda Nagar

We provide features to track your goods in real time and also ask for timely updates from us about movers and packers in Jubilee Hills. Customers can go through dispatch details and check the movement of their belongings, pickup timings. You can contact us regarding any help in the tracking of your goods. Expect quality service for us and make your shifting experience a happy one. Happy moving and we hope to serve you soon!
movers and packers in Jubilee Hills

movers and packers in - Kondapur is the perceptible service provider of packaging and relocation of commercial and household goods from one place to another place with absolute security and trustworthiness. movers and packers in Kondapur (movers and packers) render these services all over the India.
movers and packers in Kondapur

Now a day’s shifting from one place to another is became very hectic and tedious job. But in your area it is just like to get cream from milk; Packers and Movers in Kukatpally - Hyderabad is there to help each and every point.
Movers and Packers in Kukatpally

Are you living in Madhapur and looking for relocating from Madhapur to any other area within Kondapur? Packing and Moving within city looks easy task in the first look. However, if you have experienced it earlier, you will have a different idea! Relocating within the same city is as stressfull as relocating to another city. movers and packers Madhapur make your moving as simple as possible. You can sit back and relax while our expert moving and packing assistants can help you do the job.
movers and packers in Madhapur

Post a Comment

Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More