advertisement

Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Expert Witness Credibility: What Makes An Expert Believable?

Can you believe this guy? Being an expert is not enough
when it comes to credibility on the witness stand.

In order for an expert witness's testimony to be helpful in a legal case, it has to fit well into the attorney's overall legal argument. The testimony must clarify or prove certain elements of the attorney's case, and it must be persuasive. It is not enough for an expert to coldly present facts and opinions--The trier-of-fact (either the jury or the judge) also needs to believe the expert witness.

There are plenty of examples of experts who present very good opinions in very bad ways. These experts spend hours pouring over the data, reading relevant research, and forming their opinions. Then, they get on the witness stand and panic. They are tense, they stumble over their words, they look frozen in place. No matter how smart they are, the jury has a hard time believing them.

Stan Brodsky, a psychologist and nationally renowned leader on the topic of expert witness testimony, has written on the topic of expert witness credibility. He and his research partners wanted to know what factors play into whether or not an expert witness is believable on the stand.

In his research, he developed a measure called the Witness Credibility Scale (Brodsky, Griffin, & Cramer 2010), where he identified four factors that underlie the concept of believability: Likability, Trustworthiness, Confidence, and Knowledge.

Except for the factor of Confidence, it appears that the higher an expert's score on the trait, the more believable he/she is in the eyes of the jury. With Confidence, moderate scores are ideal. Apparently, an expert who is overly confident is seen as less believable (and possibly more rigid in his/her thinking) than an expert who displays a moderate level of confidence.

Dr. Brodsky's research is important because we have known for a long time that a credible expert witness is going to have more of an impact on a jury than a non-credible witness. But, we have had difficulty defining exactly what constitutes credibility or believability.

Of course, experts need to formulate well-thought, honest opinions. But, they also need to present them in the most believable way. If, for example, an expert is seen as highly knowledgeable but overly confident and unlikeable, that knowledge may have little effect on a jury. A trustworthy expert who is likeable but not confident may be seen as less than credible.

One of the limitations to Dr. Brodsky's study, which he admitted readily in his conclusions section, is that he is unsure if there are overarching personality styles that may be influencing the four factors his research team identified through the Witness Credibility Scale. One hypothesis I have is that expert witness Preparation may have a strong effect on the witness's Confidence and Knowledge ratings. Although it is not a personality attribute, there are strong indications from the research that witness preparation is one of the most important factors when it comes to effective testimony. I am inclined to believe that witnesses who prepare thoroughly are going to come across on the stand as more confident and more knowledgeable in their opinions. The proper amount of witness preparation may even increase the expert's trustworthiness.

The most highly prepared, trustworthy, and knowledgeable expert can still be a jerk, though. So, likability is probably not associated with case preparation.

Thanks for reading-- Max Wachtel, Ph.D.
www.CherryCreekPsychology.com
www.Facebook.com/drmaxwachtel
www.Twitter.com/mwachtel

9 comments:

In order to be considered as an expert witness on the issues to be resolved, there should be something in the individual’s education, experience, or knowledge with regard to those particular issues that will make their testimony useful to the jury.

The chanel replica appreciably lower amount aswell provides the actualization acquainted client with the adeptness to own abundant artist accoutrements afterwards breaking the bank.Replicated handbags accomplish "staying in style" an accessible ambition for a appreciably above allocation of the http://www.docman.com/news.asp population. It is bright that affairs replicated handbags artlessly makes economical faculty for the boilerplate actualization acquainted customer and that is afterwards agnosticism the a lot of cogent agency active this booming industry. The Abode of Chanel has over the years angry into a actualization figure and has become one of a lot of apparent names of affluence products, actualization clothes, and the acclaimed Chanel handbag. The originality, artlessness of design, and around-the-clock breeding usually analyze Chanel handbags. This is embodied in a lot of of their products, be it handbags, cosmetics, perfumes, or clothes. Such exclusivity does not appear cheap, and captivation a Chanel bag is a assurance that you accept fabricated it in life. They say that apery is the sincerest anatomy of flattery, and Chanel online writing accept become victims to that adage. There is a huge industry churning out replica Chanel products, and there is a huge bazaar for the online writing because owning a Chanel backpack is something a lot of girls about dream about. One of the a lot of gucci replica iconic items is the little atramentous bag, which was fabricated acclaimed by Chanel. The amount accepting far above the ability of many, affairs a replica Chanel artefact is absolutely widespread. Most barter for replica Chanel online writing are humans who cannot allow the absolute thing, but would like to participate in the advertising of attributable the absolute item. Replica Chanel items are now broadly accessible in the accessible bazaar and are aboveboard awash on all-embracing arcade sites. They are declared in adorned accent accompanied by photos that attending just like the absolute thing. Even the account on the handbags, for archetype is just like the original, but you should never overlook that these are fabricated by sweatshops beyond with huge profits for their owners. You can be abiding that the abstracts acclimated in the accomplish are bargain and the accouterments acclimated is of a poor quality. They ability attending adequate at aboriginal glance, but not in the continued run. There are affluence of Chanel handbags awash in online food all over the world. These sites about rationalize the affidavit for possessing some of their affected products. Often, due to the inherent agreeableness of owning a Chanel bag even a affected one, abounding are addled by the louis vuitton replica actuality that they are artlessly crumbling their money on a artefact that will just not accord them achievement in the continued run.

Are you looking to ways to accrue popularity promptly? You simply require to Buy Facebook Followers to get recognized on world wide web. facebook followers

I am greatly selective about who I annunciation and I have only ever been, and stillness am, only provided to a pick few; I want to development specials , romantic, long-term protocol, with a few identified guys whose gratification is my main anxiety. a href="http://www.indbabes.in/">Escorts Agency in Gurgaon/a>

I am very glad to read the post,it is very well written.You have done hard work in writing this post and I impressed your work.
Inmotion Web Hosting Reviews

Post a Comment

Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More