advertisement

Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Psychologists Are Allowed To Make Predictions of Future Dangerousness: Barefoot v. Estelle (1983)


Due To The Testimony From Two Psychiatrists Willing To Say Anyone Is Highly Dangerous, Mental Health Professionals Are Now Allowed to Make Predictions of Future Violence

Mugshot of Thomas Barefoot from 1978
In the summer of 1978, Thomas Barefoot killed Carl Levin, a police officer from Bell County, Texas. He told one of his roommates he was going to commit a robbery after setting a fire to divert the attention of the police. On August 7, he set fire to a nightclub, and an eye witness stated he saw Mr. Barefoot approach Officer Levin from the bushes some hours later and shoot him at point blank range. Mr. Barefoot then went back to his house with a blood splattered shirt and told his roommates he needed to leave because he "wasted a cop."

Mr. Barefoot was arrested later that night at a bus station, still carrying the gun he used to commit the murder. In November of 1978, a Texas jury convicted him of murder and the same jury sentenced him to death.

Some of the crucial evidence the jury heard in deciding their sentence came from two psychiatrists, Dr. John Holbrook and Dr. James Grigson. Both psychiatrists had been hired by the prosecution to comment hypothetically on Mr. Barefoot's risk of acting out in a violent manner at some point in the future. Neither doctor had ever met or talked to Mr. Barefoot, but both claimed to be able to make reasonable predictions of future dangerousness based on their knowledge of psychology and their review of case files.

Both doctors testified it was highly likely that Mr. Barefoot would act in a violent manner in the future. They stated he was sociopathic and could not be treated for his condition. One went on to say that, on a scale of one to ten, Mr. Barefoot was "above a ten" in terms of his sociopathic problems and level of risk to the community.

Mr. Barefoot's attorneys appealed his sentence, arguing the psychiatrists were not competent to predict future dangerousness. They further argued that this incompetence violated the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments (cruel and unusual punishment & due process). The case made its way to the US Supreme Court, which made its ruling in 1983.

The Court ruled it was not, in fact, unconstitutional for the psychiatrists' testimony to be used in the sentencing hearing. The Court held that "the factfinder" (i.e. the jury) was able to weigh the evidence provided by the psychiatrists and consider its "shortcomings" in a competent manner. It also held that answering hypothetical questions regarding a prediction of risk was fine, as it fit within the rules of evidence for expert witnesses to do so. The Court stated, "The [psychiatrist's] answers to the [hypothetical] questions were so positive as to be assertions of fact and not opinion."

As I mentioned in my previous post on risk assessments, the error rate for predicting future acts of violence in 1983 was about 67%. Two-thirds of the time, psychiatrists were wrong. But, in the Barefoot case, Drs. Holbrook and Grigson were so convinced of Mr. Barefoot's future risk that the US Supreme Court considered their opinions to be "fact."

Thomas Barefoot was executed on October 30, 1984 by lethal injection. In his final statement, he asked forgiveness from Officer Levin's wife and stated the hope that she "drive the bitterness from her heart."

Dr. Grigson testified in hundreds of death penalty cases in his career. He earned the nickname "Dr. Death" for his willingness to testify against capital punishment defendants. Dr. Holbrook, who testified that Jack Ruby was not insane in another famous Texas murder case, also testified against defendants on numerous occasions.

In 1977, both psychiatrists testified at the sentencing hearing for Randall Dale Adams, also convicted of murder. They stated he was so dangerous he would definitely pose a risk to society unless he was executed. Mr. Adams was later exonerated because it was discovered he had been wrongfully convicted--he never actually killed anybody.

Thanks for reading-- Max Wachtel, Ph.D.
www.CherryCreekPsychology.com
www.Facebook.com/drmaxwachtel
www.Twitter.com/mwachtel




11 comments:


And also case seems to be even more beautiful together with prada replica full on together with That i deem it is actually created for gentlewomen. These days let me do a comparison of a usefulness. Any Sukey Celtics container is certainly good 34 by nineteen by 37 cm with regards to case 38. 5 by 12 by 26 cm. Together deliver considerable power. And publish any factors for thoughtful structure for indoors zilch budgets together with studs that will gucci replica deliver supplemental proper protection. However , Sukey Celtics container utilizing easily removed shoulder joint bracelet are usually moved surrounding the shoulder joint. The two main Sukey sacks happen to be with Gucci this year come together with cold months set. To get to prep a beautiful fashionable designer purse to your heading changing seasons, also for tag heuer replica uk him or her might possibly be terrific. If you'd like to go an internet business the fact that is skilled in the field of lose distribution, you must have a high-quality product or service to dispose of towards your visitors via the internet. Any clients for at this time get ever more sensible. These fully understand hublot replica sale to be low priced to shop via the internet professionals who log in get hold of superior solutions at the same time. Among the many solutions which you can provide stands out as the fashionable shopping bags. Sacks really don't go out of way. They're just at all times certainly, there together with hublot replica sale ındividuals are at all times deploying it that can put details there. The ones fashionable shopping bags which include LV, Train, Burberry value a fortune but yet you will still find lots of individuals what person purchase them. That means, considerably more . promote at the time you input the line of job.


تعد المدينة المنورة من ارقى مناطق المملكة و تتميز بالطابع الدافئ والتواصل بين سكانها واجتماعهم في المناسبات المختلفه من هنا جاءت اهمية شركة تنظيف منازل بالمدينة المنورة لتقديم خدمات التنظيف للبيوت والمنازل والفلل والقصور والشقق والمدارس
ولاننا ندرك بان الفلل تحتاج الى عمالة مدربة على تنظيف الاماكن الواسعة ولديها القدر فالاول لمهارة عمالها تعد افضل افضل شركة تنظيف فلل بالمدينة المنورة تتميز بسرعة اداء عمالها في تقديم خدمة شركات تنظيف فلل بالمدينة المنورة نتميز باننا افضل شركات تنظيف الفلل بالمدينة المنورة
وكثيرا ما تحتوى الفلل على عدة خزانات فلابد من الاستعانة بافضل افضل شركة تنظيف خزانات بالمدينة المنورة فهى تستخدم افضل منظفات الخزانات والمطهرات
ولاننا افضل شركة غسيل شقق بالمدينة المنورة نقدم افضل خدمة تنظيف شقق بالمدينة المنورة بالاعتماد على افضل منظفات الكنب والستائر بالبخار
افضل شركة تنظيف شقق بالمدينة المنورة
____________________________________
افضل شركة مكافحة حشرات بالمدينة المنورة تقوم بمكافحة كافة انواع الحشرات والآفات
وكثيرا ما يحتاج سكان المدينة المنورة الى شركة نقل اثاث لنقل الاثاث من المدينة المنورة الى اى مكان داخل او خارج المملكة من هنا جاءت اهمية افضل شركة نقل عفش بالمدينة المنورة تستخدم افضل سيارات نقل العفش المخصصة
شركة تنظيف كنب بالقطيف

شركة نقل عفش بينبع -
______________________________________

تعتبر تسربات المياه من احد المشكلات التى لابد ان نقوم بحلها على الفور لان تسربات المياه تؤدى الى عدد كبير من المشكلات نحن فى غنى عنها فالاول شركة كشف تسربات بالمدينة المنورة تعتمد على افضل الاجهزه والالات المخصصه باعمال الكشف عن تسربات المياه فلا داعى للقلق من شان التسربات على الاطلاق فتذكر عزيزى العميل ان افضل شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالمدينة المنورةعلى اتم استعداد للوصول الى اى مكان بالمدينة

شركة اتقان الرياض للديكور

يعد الديكور من اهم عناصر جمال المنزل ورونقه نقدم افضل ديكورات ودهانات بافضل الدهانات العالمية العالية الجودة ونتميز بتقديم احدث تصميمات الديكور العالمية التى تعمل على جعل منزلك انيقا فخما ومريحا عمليا بالاضافة الى خدمات تنظيف السجاد وتنظيف الموكيت وتنظيف الكنب بجميع انواعه
نتميز باننا الافضل والاعلى جودة ولكن اسعارنا في متناول الجميع
مقاول دهانات بالرياض
تركيب جبس بورد بالرياض
شركة ديكورات وتشطيبات بالرياض
تشطيب فلل بالرياض
_________
شركة تصميم ديكور بالرياض

شركة تنظيف خزانات بالباحة
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالباحه
__________
تشطيب شقق بالرياض
فني تركيب ورق جدران بالرياض
افضل شركة غسيل كنب بالرياض
افضل شركة تنظيف موكيت بالرياض
شركة رش مبيدات بالباحه
شركة تنظيف منازل بالباحة


شركة عزل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة

افضل مواد العزل لخزان مثالي خالي من العيوب مع شركة فرسان الخليج شركة عزل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة التي تقدم اقوي الخصومات و عروض الاسعار علي كافة خدماتها في عزل خزانات , تنزيف خزانات بالمدينة المنورة
شركة فرسان الخليج شركة عزل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة تعتمد علي افضل الفنيين و الخبراء
مع استخدمان افضل الوسائل العلمية لحصولكم علي افضل مياة صحية

اتصلوا بنا
0553061333

شركة عزل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة


http://www.forsan-elkhaleg.com/19/Cleaning-tanks-company-in-Madinah

“If you have to narrow Replica handbags sleeves worn or tightening cuffs, you, thinner, you may need to watch” can feel or off healthy overall handbag replica appearance, he said.A typical example: look mysterious movement of. Replica Watches , I floating in the air hand appeared. “This is, they is a someone who will tell you thatthey are wearing a Rolex Daytona , I would like to talk about it,” he said.Crocodile Mr. that some of the people to Replica watches UK work better than the evening.

Post a Comment

Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More