Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Psychologists Are Allowed To Make Predictions of Future Dangerousness: Barefoot v. Estelle (1983)

Due To The Testimony From Two Psychiatrists Willing To Say Anyone Is Highly Dangerous, Mental Health Professionals Are Now Allowed to Make Predictions of Future Violence

Mugshot of Thomas Barefoot from 1978
In the summer of 1978, Thomas Barefoot killed Carl Levin, a police officer from Bell County, Texas. He told one of his roommates he was going to commit a robbery after setting a fire to divert the attention of the police. On August 7, he set fire to a nightclub, and an eye witness stated he saw Mr. Barefoot approach Officer Levin from the bushes some hours later and shoot him at point blank range. Mr. Barefoot then went back to his house with a blood splattered shirt and told his roommates he needed to leave because he "wasted a cop."

Mr. Barefoot was arrested later that night at a bus station, still carrying the gun he used to commit the murder. In November of 1978, a Texas jury convicted him of murder and the same jury sentenced him to death.

Some of the crucial evidence the jury heard in deciding their sentence came from two psychiatrists, Dr. John Holbrook and Dr. James Grigson. Both psychiatrists had been hired by the prosecution to comment hypothetically on Mr. Barefoot's risk of acting out in a violent manner at some point in the future. Neither doctor had ever met or talked to Mr. Barefoot, but both claimed to be able to make reasonable predictions of future dangerousness based on their knowledge of psychology and their review of case files.

Both doctors testified it was highly likely that Mr. Barefoot would act in a violent manner in the future. They stated he was sociopathic and could not be treated for his condition. One went on to say that, on a scale of one to ten, Mr. Barefoot was "above a ten" in terms of his sociopathic problems and level of risk to the community.

Mr. Barefoot's attorneys appealed his sentence, arguing the psychiatrists were not competent to predict future dangerousness. They further argued that this incompetence violated the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments (cruel and unusual punishment & due process). The case made its way to the US Supreme Court, which made its ruling in 1983.

The Court ruled it was not, in fact, unconstitutional for the psychiatrists' testimony to be used in the sentencing hearing. The Court held that "the factfinder" (i.e. the jury) was able to weigh the evidence provided by the psychiatrists and consider its "shortcomings" in a competent manner. It also held that answering hypothetical questions regarding a prediction of risk was fine, as it fit within the rules of evidence for expert witnesses to do so. The Court stated, "The [psychiatrist's] answers to the [hypothetical] questions were so positive as to be assertions of fact and not opinion."

As I mentioned in my previous post on risk assessments, the error rate for predicting future acts of violence in 1983 was about 67%. Two-thirds of the time, psychiatrists were wrong. But, in the Barefoot case, Drs. Holbrook and Grigson were so convinced of Mr. Barefoot's future risk that the US Supreme Court considered their opinions to be "fact."

Thomas Barefoot was executed on October 30, 1984 by lethal injection. In his final statement, he asked forgiveness from Officer Levin's wife and stated the hope that she "drive the bitterness from her heart."

Dr. Grigson testified in hundreds of death penalty cases in his career. He earned the nickname "Dr. Death" for his willingness to testify against capital punishment defendants. Dr. Holbrook, who testified that Jack Ruby was not insane in another famous Texas murder case, also testified against defendants on numerous occasions.

In 1977, both psychiatrists testified at the sentencing hearing for Randall Dale Adams, also convicted of murder. They stated he was so dangerous he would definitely pose a risk to society unless he was executed. Mr. Adams was later exonerated because it was discovered he had been wrongfully convicted--he never actually killed anybody.

Thanks for reading-- Max Wachtel, Ph.D.


And also case seems to be even more beautiful together with prada replica full on together with That i deem it is actually created for gentlewomen. These days let me do a comparison of a usefulness. Any Sukey Celtics container is certainly good 34 by nineteen by 37 cm with regards to case 38. 5 by 12 by 26 cm. Together deliver considerable power. And publish any factors for thoughtful structure for indoors zilch budgets together with studs that will gucci replica deliver supplemental proper protection. However , Sukey Celtics container utilizing easily removed shoulder joint bracelet are usually moved surrounding the shoulder joint. The two main Sukey sacks happen to be with Gucci this year come together with cold months set. To get to prep a beautiful fashionable designer purse to your heading changing seasons, also for tag heuer replica uk him or her might possibly be terrific. If you'd like to go an internet business the fact that is skilled in the field of lose distribution, you must have a high-quality product or service to dispose of towards your visitors via the internet. Any clients for at this time get ever more sensible. These fully understand hublot replica sale to be low priced to shop via the internet professionals who log in get hold of superior solutions at the same time. Among the many solutions which you can provide stands out as the fashionable shopping bags. Sacks really don't go out of way. They're just at all times certainly, there together with hublot replica sale ındividuals are at all times deploying it that can put details there. The ones fashionable shopping bags which include LV, Train, Burberry value a fortune but yet you will still find lots of individuals what person purchase them. That means, considerably more . promote at the time you input the line of job.

شركة عزل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة

افضل مواد العزل لخزان مثالي خالي من العيوب مع شركة فرسان الخليج شركة عزل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة التي تقدم اقوي الخصومات و عروض الاسعار علي كافة خدماتها في عزل خزانات , تنزيف خزانات بالمدينة المنورة
شركة فرسان الخليج شركة عزل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة تعتمد علي افضل الفنيين و الخبراء
مع استخدمان افضل الوسائل العلمية لحصولكم علي افضل مياة صحية

اتصلوا بنا

شركة عزل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة

Taking out an automobile title advance to build you credit isn't just purposeless, since car title advance moneylenders don't answer to credit agencies, however can place you in a trading off position fiscally as they convey high financing costs and advance expenses.
Payday Loans
Payday Loans
Car Title Loans
Cash Advance Chula-vista
Payday Loans Corona

This is one the best blogs i have ever come across on the internet. Have been reading posts from your blog, really interesting.
Independence Day Speech in Malayalam

Are you sophisticated with your old fashioned toilet flushing that doesn’t feel comfortable at all? This Best Flushing Toilet review will be helpful for an individual like you who are looking for some top quality flushing toilet.

A super successful character, Veronica in Black Swan,Ksenia Solo is a name of a solid performer. Through her amazing body and glamour, she proved as a serious actress in the industry.

If You Want to Buy Any Massager, You Need to Read Massager Features, Massager Details, Massager Description, Massager Specification, Massager Ratting, Pros and Cons. If You Want to Learn More Massager Review Visit our Best Massager Reviews Website.

اقوي العروض و الخصومات الان شركة رش النمل الابيض مكةعلي جميع اعمال التنظيف و مكافحة الحشرات شركة جلي رخام مكة كما يوجد جلي رخام باحدث الوسائل شركة تنظيف مكة من خلال افضل العمال المتخصصين في هذا المجال شركة تنظيف سجاد مكة من خلال افضل الطرق و التي تقضي علي اصعب البقع شركة غسيل خزانات مكة تواصلو معنا الان من خلال موقعنا

فريق عمل متخصص من شركة نقل عفش بالطائف يمكنك التواصل معه ومن اي مكان للتعرف علي افضل العروض والخدمات في شركة تنظيف مفروشات بالطائف فقط تعرف علي المزيد من الخدمات الان ومن خلال مجموعه مدربة علي اعلي مستوي في التعامل مع البقع لخدمة ربة المنزل من خلال شركة تنظيف منازل بالطائف مع توفير وقت ومجهود الكثير من العملاء كل ما عليك هو التواصل معنا وطلب خدمات شركة تنظيف خزانات بالطائف احصل علي الافضل في اي وقت ومن خلال فريق شركة جلي سيراميك بالطائف الان وفي اسرع وقت ممكن تلقي طلبات اهم واكبر شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بالطائف مع التخلص التام من الحشرات في اسرع وقت ممكن وعلي ايدي مجموعه علي استعداد تام لتلقي طلبات المزيد من خلال اكبر شركة مكافحة حشرات بالطائف تواصل معنا الان وفي اسرع وقت مع العمل يوميا ومن خلال خبراء لاعمال التنظيف وابادة الحشرات فورا .

La meilleure Replique Montre pas cher boutique de France. Delicieusement fait et Rolex,Omega,Breitling,Hublot repliques de copie de qualite a vendre

well we cant take it that these people can predict futures just because they are psychologist, they are humans too and they make mistakes.

nigerian prison recruitment

nigerian prison recruitment

If You Want to Buy Any Massager, You Need to Read Massager Features, Massager Details, Massager Description, Massager Specification, Massager Ratting, Pros and Cons. If You Want to Learn More Massager Review Visit samsung a50 price and If You Want to Buy Any Massager, You Need to Read Massager Features, Massager Details, Massager Description, Massager samsung a50 price and Specification, Massager Ratting, Pros and Cons. If You Want to Learn More Massager Review Visit

Sewage disposal company in the news Gulf Homes Company is one of the largest, most important and best companies, because it has the ability to all the problems faced by all residents, because of the sewage blockage that exist in homes, companies.

A water leak detection company in Qatif

Qatif water leakage detection company, water leakage is one of the serious and difficult problems that the population suffers because it causes cracks and cracks in the buildings and may also lead to the collapse of the entire buildings.

Sewerage disposal company in Qatif

Sewage disposal company in Qatif, the sewage blockage problem is a big problem and this problem results in accumulated insects and putrid and foul odors, therefore the population suffers from discomfort and they want a solution in order to get rid of the harmful problem.

Gulf Homes Home Services Company in Saudi Arabia

The Dear author has gone through so much thinking and research for writing this article. Thank you for sharing this great article with us. This blog is worth to read. Keep sharing this kind of post in the future. I’m also an author. So if you have time, I invite you to have a look at my site. Have a nice day!
This article is really good.Thanks.

Our Escorts Services in Islamabad are not hesitant to endeavor another position or sexual activities. You will in like manner glad to visit our escorts office as we are available in every one of the 5-star lodgings.

Escorts in Islamabad

Islamabad Escorts

Call Girls in Islamabad

شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض 0500091013 ارخص شركة نقل عفش – إدارة سعودية
شركة نقل عفش بالرياض نضمن للعميل عدم خدش او كسر الاثاث او تجريح اي قطعة من قطع العفش الخاصة بالعميل لذلك نحن افضل شركة نقل عفش وتغليف بالرياض و لدينا افضل وارخص اسعار نقل الاثاث التي تميزنا عن شركات ومكاتب ومؤسسات نقل العفش الاخري .نقل عفش بالرياض
ومن مميزات شركتنا انها تقوم بنقل العفش فى الرياض عن طريق :
نقل العفش باستخدام سيارات حديثة .
نقل العفش باستخدام ناقلات الاثاث .
نقل العفش بالاعتماد على الاوناش .
العمالة الفنية مدربة و ذو خبرة عالية من تقديم أفضل النتائج في اسرع وقت ممكن .
طريقة النقل تتوقف على حجم العفش المنقول و نوعه ، فكل قطعة من الاثاث
نستخدم لها ما يناسبها لنقلها كى تطمئنوا على العفش المراد نقله بالكامل و عدم تعريضه لاى خدوش او كسور او تلف .
الشركة تعتمد علي أفضل الأساليب الحديثة و الدقيقة في نقل الأثاث و تضمن لكل عملائها السلامة و الأمان لجميع المنقولات و الوصول لوجهتها دون ضرر ، كل هذا بأسعار مميزة تناسب جميع طبقات مجتمعنا
شركة القمة لنقل الأثاث في الرياض تساعدك علي القيام بعملية النقل بصورة سليمة و آمنة تماما فهي شركة متخصصة في عالم نقل الأثاث و تتميز بخدماتها المتعددة و المتنوعة تهدف من خلالها نقل آمن و سريع للمنقولات الخاصة بكم دون عناء أو مشقة أو تحمل تكاليف مادية باهظة أو تعرض الاثاث الخاص بكم الي كسور او الخدوش أو التلف أثناء نقله من مكان لآخر
تخزين اثاث في الرياض
لدينا افضل الطرق والتقنيات في تخزين الاثاث لاطول فترة دون المساس به او اتلافه
و نقوم بتغليف الاثاثذلك باستخدام أفضل أنواع مواد التغليف ثم نقوم بوضعه في كراتين و صناديق متينة مرقمة و ذلك حتي لا ننسي أي قطعة من قطع الأثاث ، بعد ذلك يبدأ العمال بتنزيل العفش و تحميله داخل السيارات و غالبآ يتم تنزيل العفش عن طريق الأوناش الهيدروكليكية و السلالم الكهربائية و ذلك لضيق المداخل و بعد أن يتم تحميل العفش داخل السيارات تبدأ السيارات بالتحرك و معها العمال و ذلك لتركيب العفش في المكان الجديد و يتم توصيل العفش للعميل كما كان دون خدش أو كسر فنحن نحرص تماما علي سلامة كل قطعة من العفش سواء صغيرة أو كبيرة .

نقل اثاث بالرياض
[URL=]نقل اثاث بالرياض[/URL]

For everyone who wants to check their NSCDC Shortlisted Candidates should get it here.

There are many things you can do in stranded deep game, and one of them is to craft and use speargun in the game. مؤسسة ابداع للصيانه والتشغيل

I am amazing glad that you I succeeded login to your blog today. You are wonderful, please keep it up. Hope to read more article from your article. Click Here- funai post utme question

Thanks for sharing this, but don't forget to keep a date with the viewers. Its educating one and an amazing updates and good stuff here. Great piece of information. Click Here - funai post utme past question

Flex Wall Permeability Apparatus, Soil Testing Device, Soil Testing Machine -

This comment has been removed by the author.
This comment has been removed by the author.
This comment has been removed by the author.
This comment has been removed by the author.

Future prediction by the professional psychiatrists is not always correct, based on the mental health of one person, other can not be judged as they could also do the same. I was reading more on cases about these predictions by psychologists which came out right or went wrong. To read about this from various websites, NordVPN 3 Year service was really helpful because using this VPN , i can research more on this prediction cases from around the world.

Students have been Searching for MBOSE SSLC important Question Paper 2023 All Subject Pdf Available in this page for Download. Students are Requested to get them Downloaded From Online before it is too close to the Public Exam so as to Start the Preparation on an early note, Meghalaya Board SSLC Question Paper 2023 as Usually Designed by the Professionals who are aware of the Blueprint 2023 Followed by the board from the very Start. [URL=]MBOSE SSLC Question Paper 2023[/URL] So it is Recommended to the Students to Download the MBOSE SSLC Model Paper 2023 PDF File Practice them for much benefits. MBOSE SSLC Model Question Paper 2023 are Available in English, Hindi, Mathematics, Science, Social Science etc, Students can Simply Click on the Downloadable Link of the Respective Blueprint 2023 to Download it for Free, So, to help out the Exam Appearing Students, we had Collected Complete Information and Furnished here on this page.

Board of High School and Intermediate Education Uttar Pradesh (BHSIEUP) is the Uttar Pradesh State Government Administered Autonomous UP Board 11th Class Book 2023 Examining Authority is an Educational board in the state of Uttar Pradesh Adopted the Curriculum and Text Book National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT), Students Download UP Board 11th new Textbook 2023s 2023 for NCERT it is Very useful, UP State Students get your 11th Class Study Material Useful by NCERT, Visit NCERT Official Website get Study Material All Subject Wise Pdf Format

ماكينات لحام البولى ايثلين هي آلة تستخدم لتشكيل البلاستيك المصهور إلى أشكال وأحجام مختلفة هناك العديد من الأنواع المختلفة لآلات نفخ البلاستيك،

تشركات تركيب واجهات زجاجية في مصر يَأْتي بعدة مزايا كبيرة تساعد في زيادة التأثير والوضوح وتحسين المنظر العام. يشكل الزجاج نوعًا من المادة المتجددة الخصبة لتحسين الابداع الهندسي والروعة الإستنادية. إن تركيب الواجهات الزجاجيّة يتيح عدّة مزايا متعددة

غرغرينا القدم السكري من الامراض الخطيرة التي تصيب مرضي السكر ويجب سرعه التوجه للدكتور محمود ناصر لتلاقي العلاج المناسب لحالتك .

At Jawhara Clean Company, we have a well-trained and qualified team in all household skills. We work hard to provide the best services. Whether you need to clean the house, or school, or you need the service of a private chef to prepare delicious meals, we are here for all of them.

The design of this GOLD BRASS RING is so unique and eye-catching. I appreciate how it effortlessly blends classic and contemporary elements, making it a statement piece that stands out without being overly flashy.

Post a Comment


Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More