advertisement

Thursday, October 18, 2012

Dr. Death And The Violation of The Fifth Amendment: Estelle v. Smith (1981)

Ernest Smith, From Texas Monthly
Magazine, July 1978
Dr. Death makes another appearance in a landmark U.S. Supreme Court Case. In a post from earlier this year, I outlined the case of Barefoot v. Estelle, where Dr. James Grigson stated a defendant was so dangerous he would definitely kill again, despite never having met that defendant. Not exactly psychiatry's proudest moment--and keep in mind, this is a profession that used to scramble people's brains with an ice pick driven through their eye sockets.

In a 1973 murder case from Texas, Dr. Grigson was hired to conduct a pretrial competency evaluation. The case involved Ernest Smith, who was arrested for participating in an armed robbery where an accomplice killed a grocery store clerk. Dr. Grigson reported that Mr. Smith was competent to stand trial and he labeled Mr. Smith a "severe sociopath." Interestingly, Mr. Smith's defense team had no idea that Dr. Grigson had evaluated him until they received the competency report filed with the court (this would never happen today. The process for obtaining a competency evaluation is clear and open).

Mr. Smith's case went to trial, and a jury convicted him. Prosecutors sought the death penalty, and one of the criteria the jury needed to weigh was the future dangerousness of the convicted defendant. Prosecutors called Dr. Grigson as a witness, who had only met with Mr. Smith for the pretrial, court-ordered competency evaluation. He testified that Mr. Smith remained highly dangerous and thus posed a continued risk to society. But really, did you expect Dr. Grigson to have any other opinion? He would have testified that a potted plant posed a danger to society if the death penalty were in question.

Based largely on Dr. Grigson's testimony, the jury decided the prosecution had made its case, and Mr. Smith was sentenced to death.

As is expected in every death sentence case, Mr. Smith appealed his conviction (in fact, an appeal was mandatory in Texas at the time). The case worked its way through the courts and ended up at the U.S. Supreme Court in October of 1980. Mr. Smith argued that by using the forced competency evaluation in his sentencing phase, his Fifth Amendment Rights against self incrimination were violated.

The Court agreed with Mr. Smith's argument. In their decision from 1981, the Court held, "(1) the admission of the psychiatrist's testimony violated the defendant's Fifth Amendment privilege against compelled self-incrimination, since the defendant was not advised before the pretrial examination that he had a right to remain silent and that any statement he made could be used against him at the sentencing proceeding, the defendant's statements to the psychiatrist when faced while in custody with a court-ordered psychiatric examination not being given freely and voluntarily without any compelling influence so that they could be used at the penalty phase only if the defendant had been apprised of his rights and had knowingly decided to waive them, and (2) the admission of the psychiatrist's testimony violated the defendant's Sixth Amendment right to the assistance of counsel, since defense counsel were not notified in advance that the psychiatric examination would encompass the issue of their client's future dangerousness and the defendant was denied the assistance of his attorney in making the significant decision of whether to submit to the examination and to what end the psychiatrist's findings could be employed, the Sixth Amendment right attaching when the doctor examined the defendant in jail and that interview proving to be a "critical stage" of the aggregate proceedings against the defendant."

In other words, the Court was insistent that Mr. Smith's Fifth Amendment Right had been violated because he was never informed during the court-ordered (in other words, forced) evaluation that he had the right to remain silent and that information he provided to the evaluator would be used against him at sentencing. And, the Court took their decision one step further: they held that Mr. Smith's Sixth Amendment Right to Counsel was violated because his defense team was never notified that the competency evaluation would be used to sentence him to death.

In subsequent cases now codified into state laws, data collected in court ordered competency evaluations cannot be used during the trial or sentencing phases of an individual's court case, unless the defendant raises the issue of his mental health as part of his defense and rebuttal testimony is needed.


Dr. James Grigson, trying to blind the photographer,
from Texas Monthly Magazine, July 1978
Interestingly, in a Texas Court of Criminal Appeals opinion on this case, Judge Wendell Odom wrote, "Dr. Grigson's qualifications as a psychiatrist may be fine, but I find no testimony which qualifies him as an expert in predicting the future...It is my opinion that such future-telling testimony is admissible under no theory of law and prejudicial beyond belief...I am unable to find that much of the testimony offered was from this side of the twilight zone," (From Texas Monthly Magazine, 1978).

Thanks for reading-- Max Wachtel, Ph.D.



72 comments:

Forensic science helps in finding the hidden truth, which we can't see,the way it works is awesome.

A different sentencing continuing was then held before the same jury as required by Texas law. At such a procedure the jury must resolve three basic issues to figure out if or not capital punishment will be forced.

thesis writing service UK

This comment has been removed by the author.

I wonder if dr. Phil McGraw was trained by this doctor death? Texas should be a country outside of America.

It's a valuable piece of information about the different aspects of laws. i prefer some of your ideas to write my law thesis. It will be available in thesis writing service

I always keep in mind the information you have shared. The theory of law and prejudicial are always beyond the belief. I want to write such informative article by taking help from case study report writing service.

It was a tremendous write-up and shares some thrilling psychological elements. It explains some psychological facts by using some examples from real life. Recently, I have seen some brilliant psychology related articles in essay writing service USA

طرق كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض

طرق الكشف عن تسربات المياه التقليدية من الطرق السيئة التى تحتاج الى الكسر والتبليط وتحتاج الى الكثير من الوقت والجهد والاموال لذلك قررت شركتنا ان تعتمد على افضل الالات والاجهزة المميزة التى تساعد فى التعرف على مكان التسرب من خلال افضل الاجهزة فيقوم العاملين بالتحرك بالجهاز المميز والتى يساعد فى التعرف على مكان التسرب فى اقل وقت ممكن فالجهاز يصدر ذبذبات يساعد فى القيام بالتعرف على مكان التسرب
تعد شركة الاول افضل شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالاحساء
- شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالقطيف
- و افضل شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالدمام
- وافضل شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالجبيل
- و افضل شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض
افضل شركة نظافة بالرياض
- و شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالمدينة المنورة
افضل شركة صيانة مكيفات بالرياض
شركة ترميم فلل بالرياض
واسعارها في متناول الجميع ومن الهام التاكد دائما من خلو منزلك من تسربات المياه حتى لا تتعرض لمشاكل مثل انهيار وتصدع المبانى الاول افضل شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض تستخدم اجهزه الكترونية اكشف التسرب بالذبذبات وتغطى كافة مناطق الرياض فهى افضل شركة كشف تسربات المياه شرق الرياض

This is an fiction like blog. It is very interesting. Keep posting blogs. Best Wishes.

Dissertation Writing Service

This comment has been removed by the author.

Hey it was amazing. Thanks for share with us. When I read this, I got feeling that I am reading a fictional story.

research paper writing service

This blog is really interesting. Enjoyed reading it. Thank you buy essays online

As a rule, credit union will bring down your regularly scheduled installment request by concentrating the greater part of your government advances into one in which you will have up to 30 years to reimburse. You will have the capacity to switch any factor enthusiasm to a settled rate. aaa1autotitleloans.com/chicago

When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added obat flek paru-paru- checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get four emails with the same comment. Is obat penyakit paru-paru there any way you can remove me from that service? Thanks!


I know how it's an awesome game so I real want to Play it haha :) :)
tank trouble6
tanktrouble-6
cabanova
tanktrouble-6
page
bravesites

HSBC additionally gives home advances which make it simpler for you to move in as quickly as time permits without putting a strain on your budgetary condition. HSBC gives home credits extending from 5 lakhs to 3 crores. check cashing

Thanks for sharing post. It is really good one which provide enough information to explore about given topic. Good luck.
Coursework writing services

I don?t know if best practices have emerged around things obat sinusitis like that, but I am sure that your job is obat kudis clearly identified as a fair game. Both boys and girls feel obat radang usus the impact of just a moment’s pleasureobat penghilang bekas cacar air, for the rest of their lives obat tukak lambung.

You made some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the issue of obat herpes simplex and found most individuals will go along with with your website.

Hello! I just obat diare would like to give a huge thumbs up obat penyakit tbc for the great info you have here on this postobat tukak lambung. I will be coming back to your blog for more soon. obat infekis kencing kencing obat sesak nafas akibat asma lambung

WONDERFUL Post.thanks for share... obat penyakit kudis - There are certainly a lot of details like that to take into consideration. That is a great point to bring obat eksim basah up. - cara mengobati sesak nafas - obat osteoarthritis

Youre so cool! I dont obat penghilang stretch mark suppose Ive read anything like this obat limpa bengkak before. So nice to find somebody with some original thoughts on this subject. realy thank you for starting obat radang paru-paru this up.

I am grateful to have found this article obat penghilang jamur di selangkangan. This article is so menginsripasi me, so did my friends obat tendinitis. because of this article I share with classmates on campus obat alami kudis. thanks.

I have completed my task (obat nyeri sendi). and this is thanks to some posts on this blog. This blog once "obat luka lambung", may continue passionate in writing.

Indeed Sharing Beautiful ITU obat isk. And yes, this blog has been split Various Posts Its very useful for a obat nyeri ulu hati wide audience, especially the main I. - obat nyeri dada tengah

Of the many blogs that I follow (obat maag untuk ibu hamil), not many blogs whose content like this, I was blessed to find this blog (obat ulu hati perih). Thank you for offering variety of interesting articles, are also useful. cara mengobati ginjal bengkak

many posts on this blog. the quality of any content is good obat benjolan lipoma, it seems too many visitors. I thank you for presenting this paper to us of obat infeksi saluran kencing. my friends also sometimes visiting here obat flek paru-paru. thanks.

a fraction this blog post is somewhat less understood, but more so exciting, educating, benefits (obat gagal ginjal), inspire, and many other expressions. anyway thanks for all this writing, thank you. obat penyakit paru-paru

Thank you for sharing with us this insight is lacking. the attractiveness, usefulness, it feels when I finished reading the written language in this blog [obat gatal-gatal merah di badan]. Thanks to all authors. a bit of advice, however, that the author put forward his every interaction. - obat penghilang keloid yang sudah lama

I am finished with this blog, with posts in this blog I smiled, with this sort of my knowledge increased, thanks author. keep the spirit in writing, continuously creative, hopefully blessing. - obat herpes simplex - cara mengobati sinusitis

seems like one writing on this blog is the same with the blog I have ever visited a month ago, but it might be just me. Hehe .. But, it posts here interesting attraction, as well as educational (obat penyakit miom). obat cacar air - obat vulvovaginitis

a lot of my friends who said that the variety of writing on this blog is very inspiring. some also demonstrating the benefits eduksinya. including me, writing here helps me a lot in college assignments. obat gerd atau asam lambung + obat radang sendi akibat asam urat

Thank you in advance for giving us a lot of inspiration. not only that, the benefits of education, skills are also in this blog. many tasks as well as I finish through the aid of this blog. obat anyang-anyangan - cara mengatasi sakit ulu hati

Among some of the blogs that I bookmark, the only two that I can rely on. One of the two is this blog. There are many reasons why I choose this blog, the value of education, is one of them. obat tipes obat kurap di selangkangan obat eksim basah

really nice to find this in the blog posts as cool as you. Inspire, educate, and so much more value in each content. obat muntaber anak obat ispa

This comment has been removed by the author.

blog competition may be the author of an as an appreciation of yourself. especially the quality of the writing here have a lot to admit. Assume tendencies search experience. thanks. obat benjolan yang terasa sakit - obat tipes

expletive ever catapult (obat biang keringat di wajah), because one of the blog's content is offensive to me and obat flek paru-paru. but, it was paid for with a variety of interesting content, inspire and educate in this blog. cara mengobati radang kandung empedu

I'm always happy to follow this blog post. cool various posts here on friends in socialcc media, various comments always fulfill my social media posts. many benefits, thanks writer, keeps the spirit. - obat sesak nafas karena asma - obat telinga berair dan berbau

I was touched to see an issue that is still confusing, but now is not the case, because this blog has opened up everything. thanks. obat batuk bronkitis, obat penghilang keloid

has been a lot of articles on this blog that I keep as a reliable reference. thanks author, the spirit continues to write cara menghilangkan gatal pada kemaluan pria, obat penghilang bintitan

not only provide benefits to us as visitors, this blog also gives us an insight to earn money online, thanks. obat qnc jelly gamat

These weeks I have never visited this blog, because the writing has been long enough to stop. But here I try to reopen it, and unexpectedly the writing has been updated again. http://greenujer.blogspot.com/2017/04/salep-ruam-popok-bayi-paling-ampuh.html http://greenujer.blogspot.com/2016/05/cara-mengobati-gagal-ginjal-selain-cuci.html

These weeks I have never visited this blog, because the writing has been long enough to stop. But here I try to reopen it, and unexpectedly the writing has been updated again. cara menghilangkan ruam popok bayi pengobatan gagal ginjal

i put this comment cause i feel content your provide very useful. thanks you very much. obat infeksi saluran kemih

Thanks for the information presented on your website
Very in waiting for other information

obat penyakit kuning
obat limpa bengkak mujarab
tanaman obat tradisional infeksi rahim

The information from this site is very helpful so it is in waiting for other latest information

buah infeksi lambung
gejala radang paru paru
bahaya hepatitis ibu hamil
obat ginjal bengkak tradisional


Your site is the best
The latest information we are waiting for lho..semoga what is given can be useful
Terimakash..success always everything..salam know ..

obat ginjal kronis tradisional manjur
pengobatan diabetes melitus secara tradisional
obat penurun trigliserida tinggi

Get All Latest Jobs, Results, Answer Key, Admit Card And Career News Website (Up-to-date Data)
[url=http://indiajobsdekho.com/]IndiaJobsDekho.com[/url]

Sites like these I'm looking for
Thanks for the information, in tunggua keep the latest news

cara sembuhkan gagal ginjal
obat haid tidak teratur manjur

This is one of the best information I found today, I am very happy because I can find information that is very interesting, This information is very good, and very useful to me, Maybe I will visit this site in the future, and of course I will also tell my friends that there is a very interesting site for them visit.

Obat Abses Payudara Obat Nyeri Tulang Ekor Obat Sakit Gigi Berlubang Obat Benjolan Di Rahim Obat Ginjal Bengkak Obat Nyeri Punggung Obat Nyeri Lambung Obat Nyeri Saat Kencing Obat Jerawat Pasir Di Wajah Obat Jerawat Kecil Di Wajah

Post a Comment

Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More