advertisement

Thursday, October 18, 2012

Dr. Death And The Violation of The Fifth Amendment: Estelle v. Smith (1981)

Ernest Smith, From Texas Monthly
Magazine, July 1978
Dr. Death makes another appearance in a landmark U.S. Supreme Court Case. In a post from earlier this year, I outlined the case of Barefoot v. Estelle, where Dr. James Grigson stated a defendant was so dangerous he would definitely kill again, despite never having met that defendant. Not exactly psychiatry's proudest moment--and keep in mind, this is a profession that used to scramble people's brains with an ice pick driven through their eye sockets.

In a 1973 murder case from Texas, Dr. Grigson was hired to conduct a pretrial competency evaluation. The case involved Ernest Smith, who was arrested for participating in an armed robbery where an accomplice killed a grocery store clerk. Dr. Grigson reported that Mr. Smith was competent to stand trial and he labeled Mr. Smith a "severe sociopath." Interestingly, Mr. Smith's defense team had no idea that Dr. Grigson had evaluated him until they received the competency report filed with the court (this would never happen today. The process for obtaining a competency evaluation is clear and open).

Mr. Smith's case went to trial, and a jury convicted him. Prosecutors sought the death penalty, and one of the criteria the jury needed to weigh was the future dangerousness of the convicted defendant. Prosecutors called Dr. Grigson as a witness, who had only met with Mr. Smith for the pretrial, court-ordered competency evaluation. He testified that Mr. Smith remained highly dangerous and thus posed a continued risk to society. But really, did you expect Dr. Grigson to have any other opinion? He would have testified that a potted plant posed a danger to society if the death penalty were in question.

Based largely on Dr. Grigson's testimony, the jury decided the prosecution had made its case, and Mr. Smith was sentenced to death.

As is expected in every death sentence case, Mr. Smith appealed his conviction (in fact, an appeal was mandatory in Texas at the time). The case worked its way through the courts and ended up at the U.S. Supreme Court in October of 1980. Mr. Smith argued that by using the forced competency evaluation in his sentencing phase, his Fifth Amendment Rights against self incrimination were violated.

The Court agreed with Mr. Smith's argument. In their decision from 1981, the Court held, "(1) the admission of the psychiatrist's testimony violated the defendant's Fifth Amendment privilege against compelled self-incrimination, since the defendant was not advised before the pretrial examination that he had a right to remain silent and that any statement he made could be used against him at the sentencing proceeding, the defendant's statements to the psychiatrist when faced while in custody with a court-ordered psychiatric examination not being given freely and voluntarily without any compelling influence so that they could be used at the penalty phase only if the defendant had been apprised of his rights and had knowingly decided to waive them, and (2) the admission of the psychiatrist's testimony violated the defendant's Sixth Amendment right to the assistance of counsel, since defense counsel were not notified in advance that the psychiatric examination would encompass the issue of their client's future dangerousness and the defendant was denied the assistance of his attorney in making the significant decision of whether to submit to the examination and to what end the psychiatrist's findings could be employed, the Sixth Amendment right attaching when the doctor examined the defendant in jail and that interview proving to be a "critical stage" of the aggregate proceedings against the defendant."

In other words, the Court was insistent that Mr. Smith's Fifth Amendment Right had been violated because he was never informed during the court-ordered (in other words, forced) evaluation that he had the right to remain silent and that information he provided to the evaluator would be used against him at sentencing. And, the Court took their decision one step further: they held that Mr. Smith's Sixth Amendment Right to Counsel was violated because his defense team was never notified that the competency evaluation would be used to sentence him to death.

In subsequent cases now codified into state laws, data collected in court ordered competency evaluations cannot be used during the trial or sentencing phases of an individual's court case, unless the defendant raises the issue of his mental health as part of his defense and rebuttal testimony is needed.


Dr. James Grigson, trying to blind the photographer,
from Texas Monthly Magazine, July 1978
Interestingly, in a Texas Court of Criminal Appeals opinion on this case, Judge Wendell Odom wrote, "Dr. Grigson's qualifications as a psychiatrist may be fine, but I find no testimony which qualifies him as an expert in predicting the future...It is my opinion that such future-telling testimony is admissible under no theory of law and prejudicial beyond belief...I am unable to find that much of the testimony offered was from this side of the twilight zone," (From Texas Monthly Magazine, 1978).

Thanks for reading-- Max Wachtel, Ph.D.



222 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 222 of 222   Newer›   Newest»

Our engineers and technicians are fully skilled in their file with 10+ years’ experience. Besides, our business is always updating with the latest technologies and trends. Choosing our support will truly provide you global expertise.
800 customer support number

Quicken Customer Service Number

Quicken Support Number

Quicken Tech Support Number

Quicken Customer Support Number

Quickbooks Customer Service Number

Quickbooks Technical Support Number

Quickbooks Customer Support Number

Quickbooks Help Number

Turbotax Customer Service Number

Entah ini hanya sebatas opini atau mitos saja cara menggugurkan kandungan dengan bumbu dapur dengan menggunakan kunyit asam maupun asam jawa , jahe maupun manjakani dan merica mampu untuk cara menggugurkan hamil . Padahal yang perlu anda ketahui resiko menggugurkan kandungan sangat berbahaya dan berat . Oleh sebab itu , anda jangan sembarangan melakukannya . telat datang bulan yang dialami wanita selalu dikaitkan dengan kehamilan , Padahal ada beberapa penyebab alat reproduksi wanita mengalami gangguan tersebut seperti stess , tidak menjaga pola makan sehat dan sebagainya . Untuk para suami agar terjalin hubungan intim yang harmonis sangat perlu sekali untuk mengetahui cara merangsang wanita supaya pasangan anda lebih bergairah dalam menjalin asmara bersama anda .

We find lots of learning after reading this very useful article . cara menggugurkan hamil

Our Buy Custom Essay Service Online is normally written by professionals who have sufficient experience in writing academic papers in any discipline. Our customer service is available 24/7, which makes it easy for clients to place orders and receive their Online Custom Essay Writing Services on time.

Very interesting blog. Alot of blogs I see these days don't really provide anything that I'm interested in, but I'm most definately interested in this one. Just thought that I would post and let you know

Agen Idn Poker Terpercaya

My travel life have been simpler with Garmin GPS Update . In addition I can get all the extra information through their websites. I utilize the Garmin application and is absolutely up to the imprint. I prescribe everybody to utilize How to update map in a garmin device and get Garmin life time map update or call +1-888-309-0939 for moment help from Garmin GPS specialists.

I didn't have a clue about the whole advantages of My Garmin Express. Be that as it may, since I have perused this blog on map update, I have introduced all accessible updates for my Garmin device. I should state that this bit of blog has helped me improve navigation understanding. I am recommending every one of my companions to peruse this blog and get Garmin Nuvi Update with this team and get Garmin life time map update or call +1-888-309-0939 for moment help from Garmin GPS specialists.

Welcome Jaipur Escorts Service. We offer Escort Service in All Locations of Jaipur Like, Bani Park, Bais Godam, Bhankrota, Sanganer, Vaishali Nagar, Near Airport, Malviya Nagar, Kukas, Raja Park and More. So Your Can Book Call Girls in Jaipur at Your Local Place.

Call Girls in Kukas
Call Girls in Raja Park
Call Girls in Vidhyadhar Nagar
Call Girls in Bajaj Nagar

If You are Looking For Escorts Service in Your City? Ascorts Club Escorts Agency - Who Provide Independent Call Girls, Model Escort, Celebrity Escort and More Kind Escorts Girls in India. Just Call us and Book Your Dream Girl.

Ascorts Club Colaba Escorts Service
Ascorts Club Santa Cruz Escorts Service
Ascorts Club Airport Escorts Service
Ascorts Club Navi Mumbai Escorts Service

If Your Looking For Call Girls and Escorts Services in Your City? Schloka - Free Adult classifieds in India, Browse in our call girl category To Post Ads, Book Escorts and Find Contact No For Hire Call Girls.

Schloka Escorts Surat
Schloka Escorts Thiruvarur
Schloka Escorts Bhavnagar
Schloka Escorts jaipur
Schloka Escorts delhi

Tamil Nadu Higher Secondary Education Department has completed the Downloading of answer sheet for class 12th / +2 Plus two examination for the year 2023 And now the TN Board is to Download the HSC/ TNDGE 12th Book 2023 12th Syllabus 2023 on 07th May, 2023. However, in the last year, TN Board HSC examination Syllabus 2023 was Download on May, 2023. Anyway if your are the student and searching for TN +2 Syllabus 2023 are advised that, you may go through the below mentioned steps or by direct links to find Tamil Nadu HSC Syllabus 2023

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 222 of 222   Newer› Newest»

Post a Comment

Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More