advertisement

Monday, October 8, 2012

Protecting Even The Most Despicable Of Defendants: Drope v. Missouri (1975)


In the US, we protect our criminal defendants. We assume even the most dastardly individuals are innocent unless proven guilty, and we make sure defendants are able to exercise all of their Constitutional Rights when defending themselves. Let me cite the case of Drope v. Missouri as an example:

In 1969, James Drope was indicted for rape. He was alleged to have forcibly raped his own wife, along with several of his acquaintances. His wife reported to the court that he and four of his friends raped her and subjected her to several other "indecencies." She reported she continued living with Mr. Drope after the rape so that her children would be taken care of, at the insistence of his psychiatrist. She also reported Mr. Drope attempted to kill her several days before his trial began.

Prior to trial, Mr. Drope's defense attorney entered a motion asking the court for a continuance so that he could receive a psychological evaluation and treatment. The motion contained a letter from a psychiatrist stating Mr. Drope did, in fact, need mental health treatment. The prosecution did not object to the motion. Nevertheless, the court denied the motion and set the case for trial.

Mr. Drope's wife testified for the prosecution, and she mentioned she was hesitant about wanting to bring charges against her husband until he attempted to kill her. She described significant, odd behavior on Mr. Drope's part. One behavior she described was Mr. Drope "roll[ing] down the stairs" if he received bad news or if something did not go his way.

On the second day of trial, Mr. Drope did not appear in court. He had shot himself in the stomach in a suicide attempt and was hospitalized. The defense asked the court to declare a mistrial. The court refused, and it ordered the defense to proceed with the trial without Mr. Drope's presence.

Needless to say, Mr. Drope was convicted. His defense team appealed the conviction, arguing he was deprived of his Due Process Rights (Fourteenth Amendment) because the court did not order a mental health evaluation and proceeded with his trial without his presence. An Appeals Court rejected the appeal, but the U.S. Supreme Court decided to hear the case.

In 1975, The Supreme Court unanimously reversed the Appeals Court decision and remanded Mr. Drope's case to the trial court to allow for a retrial, assuming he was competent at the time of the retrial.

The Court held, "(1) the defendant's due process right to a fair trial was violated by the trial
court's failure to suspend the trial pending a psychiatric examination to determine the defendant's competence to stand trial, since the wife's testimony, the psychiatrist's report, and the defendant's attempted suicide were sufficient indicia of incompetency to require such examination, (2) in view of the trial court's failure to inquire into the defendant's mental competency, there was no basis for determining whether the defendant had effectively waived his right to be present at his trial, assuming that such right could be waived, and (3) the defendant's due process rights could not be adequately protected by merely remanding for a psychiatric examination aimed at establishing whether the defendant was in fact competent at the time of the trial approximately 6 1/2 years earlier, the state being free to retry the defendant if he is competent at the time of such trial."

The Court made it clear that individuals must be competent to stand trial at the time of the trial in order to them to adequately exercise their Constitutional Rights and to avoid violations of Due Process. It also made clear that if questions arise about an individual's competency, trial courts have an obligation to suspend proceedings until the person's competency or incompetency can be established. In most states now, merely asking for a competency evaluation is enough to kick off the competency evaluation process--it is not necessary for an attorney to present evidence to the court of an individual's incompetence to start the evaluation procedure.

I do not know what happened to Mr. Drope after the Supreme Court remanded his case back to the trial court. My guess is that he underwent a competency evaluation to determine if he was fit to be tried again, and if he wasn't, he probably received restoration to competency treatment services.

Thanks for reading-- Max Wachtel, Ph.D.


5 comments:

Its essentialness that you see well what Essay Thinker Writing Service maths studies involve before setting out on them. Science is essentially a thing to do with examples

The gucci replica availability and arduous array of replica items accept been steadily accretion in contempo years. If a assertive account becomes fashionable you can be abiding that a abundant added affordable, yet about duplicate replica is already on the way. If the 18-carat commodity sells, the replica will aswell sell. If there is a accumulation to be fabricated an industry will be born. The a lot of frequently replicated affluence appurtenances cover upmarket artist clothing, shoes, sportswear, perfumes, watches, sunglasses and of chanel replica advance artist handbags. Many humans will agreeably acquirement a replica backpack as a able-bodied fabricated replica can action the aforementioned authority as the aboriginal but afterwards the about ample amount tag. The boilerplate customer can artlessly not allow to pay the abounding hundreds, even accoutrements of dollars for the advantage of accustomed an accurate Prada, Hermes or Louis Vuitton handbag. It is estimated that over 85% of all the Louis Vuitton handbags in use today are replicas. Even an big-ticket replica will about represent a atom of the amount of the aboriginal and can be around identical to the "real thing", both in above of accomplish and abstracts acclimated in production. Luxury items like artist accoutrements will of replica watches advance alter in above of architecture and absorption to detail. The packaging may aswell not be as arrant as those of an original. In accustomed though, the akin of adroitness of apish appurtenances can ambit from appropriate to outstanding. This may be attributed to the actuality that Manufactures of copies are not alone jockeying for position with the 18-carat article, but are aswell bound in antagonism with anniversary other. Some pieces will alone be adequate representations while others are about mirror images of the original. If you attending carefully though, you may anticipate some accessory differences. The cast name or logo may alter hardly from the aboriginal as may some of the architecture actualization on the bag itself. The abundance of Replica handbags calamity the prada belts artist appurtenances bazaar is no accessory cephalalgia for the above actualization houses. Top end actualization manufacturers like Louis Vuitton, Gucci, Prada and Chanel are actual alive in their efforts to avert the admeasurement of replica appurtenances and affected manufacturers that accumulation on the base of their harder becoming authority and cast names. Millions of dollars are spent by actualization manufacturers annually to adverse this growing problem. Consumers however, adulation replica artist handbags. And who can accusation them? As has already been mentioned, the amount is right! Indeed, abounding consumers acutely abode the accusation for the top prices of accurate artist appurtenances at the anxiety of the mega architecture houses themselves. Actualization houses accept been accustomed to advisedly beneath accumulation a product, thereby artificially active appeal and prices up. People will consistently covet artist actualization products. The harder and added big-ticket you accomplish them to obtain, the added accomplishment the customer will put into award an easier and beneath big-ticket agency of accepting them. The availability of top above replica handbags, agency that even the account acquainted client may adore the authority of owning a artist account that looks and feels like the absolute thing. No best are these ailing advised knockoffs that abatement afar afterwards a few days. The louis vuitton replica acute antagonism in the replica bazaar not alone leads to aggressive pricing, but aswell above quality.

Post a Comment

Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More