Tuesday, January 29, 2013

Two Cases Of Interest For The Aurora Theater Shooting: Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California (1976) & Jablonski v. U.S. (1983)

Are mental health workers supposed to help their clients,
or do they have a duty to protect the public from harm?
Dr. Lynne Fenton, the Aurora theater shooter's former psychiatrist, and the University of Colorado Hospital are facing several lawsuits from victims and victims' families. I wrote about the challenges facing the plaintiffs' attorneys in a blog post here. Assuming the attorneys are able to convince the court to order Dr. Fenton to release the shooter's records, there are two key legal cases that will play a part in the success or the failure of the lawsuits.

Tatiana Tarasoff
First, is Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California (1976). In this case, a UC-Berkeley student stalked, stabbed, and killed Tatiana Tarasoff, another student of the University. The murderer, who ended up getting off scott-free because of a technicality, had been treated for mental illness at the university's hospital. His treating psychologists failed to warn Ms. Tarasoff of the danger she was in. In 1974, the California Supreme Court ruled the university had a duty to warn her.

Two years later, the case made its way back to the California Supreme Court. At that time, the Court clarified its first ruling, and they found the university actually had a duty to protect Ms. Tarasoff. In the discharge of that duty, they stated the hospital should have notified the potential victim, called the police, and taken whatever steps that were "reasonably necessary under the circumstances." They further clarified that the university had a duty to break the killer's confidentiality in order to protect the potential victim. The most famous quote from this decision is, "The protective privilege ends where the public peril begins."

Prosenjit Poddar, Ms. Tarasoff's killer
One of the keys in the Tarasoff ruling was that the risk of violence must be such that the intended victim is in "foreseeable danger." More on that later.

The second case is Jablonski v. U.S. In this case, a man with a severe personality disorder and a history of rape and violence killed his girlfriend. The daughter of the girlfriend sued a hospital that failed to involuntarily hospitalize the man several weeks before the killing because they did not gather adequate information about him prior to making the decision to release him. The suit alleged the hospital also failed to warn the intended victim.

In this case, the trial court ruled the hospital was negligent for both above-mentioned reasons. The court ruled the hospital had an absolute duty to warn the girlfriend she was in foreseeable danger. On appeal, the Appeals Court affirmed the lower court's decision.

So, how do these cases relate to the lawsuits against Dr. Fenton? The Tarasoff decision would dictate that Dr. Fenton had a duty to protect potential victims from the shooter. Plaintiff's attorneys could argue she should have called the Aurora police and done more to escalate her concerns through the University of Colorado's emergency management system. She also could have had him involuntarily committed when campus police asked her if the shooter needed that level of care about a month before the shooting.

The tricky aspect with Tarasoff is that it is a California Supreme Court decision. Thus, it does not necessarily hold for different states. A defense attorney could argue there is no duty to protect spelled out in Colorado law the way it is in California. That is where the Jablonski decision becomes important. This was a decision through the U.S. Court of Appeals. Although it did not establish the duty to protect on the Federal level, it certainly established the duty to warn. And, the duty to protect, as it is described in the Tarasoff decision, has now become the standard of practice to which psychologists and psychiatrists are held, regardless of what state they work in.

The risk of harm is not always as foreseeable to
mental health workers as it is to this woman.
One final note: The attorneys who are suing Dr. Fenton have case law on their side, but they must prove one very important aspect regarding her treatment of the shooter--they must demonstrate Dr. Fenton knew, or should have known, there was "foreseeable danger." This will be a difficult task. First, most people who experience homicidal or suicidal thoughts never act on those thoughts. Plus, many patients will never tell their doctors about their homicidal thinking. Dr. Fenton will have had to have known about the shooter's homicidal ideation and believed it to be imminent enough that there was a duty to protect the public. Plus, she would have needed to know he had a specific plan against a person or a group of people (like a group of moviegoers).

Thanks for reading-- Max Wachtel, Ph.D.


You will discover flashy nevertheless functional tag heuer replica sale, classy along with lovely as well as a thing ordinary of their selection. Everyone will quickly realize a thing inside Suppose selection, from a young little girl for a grandpa! You can find that the Armani enjoy can be costlier compared to a Suppose enjoy nevertheless his or her splendor along with variety can be cartier replica sale worthy of the retail price. The Armani enjoy can be complex along with classy, lovely along with elegant and a lot of men and women come across something accommodates his or her distinct figure within this selection. In case you acquire reasonable earnings and then the Armani enjoy is usually an selection. Appropriate inside rolex replica sale, involving all these designer watches can be yet another selection. A new Eileen kors enjoy shows up costlier when compared with its. These are classy, lovely along with the best price tag for the enjoy that will seems to be as you need to shell out increase just how much actually distributed pertaining to. Designer watches are generally common nowadays, and you ought to look into numerous makes along with variations as it can be rolex replica sale purchasing just about any distinct one particular. Accomplish a number of analysis in order to find normally the one best suited to you personally. Since Subsequent Entire world Warfare plus the following National work, Asia features converted right intensely industrialized land. The fact that was after rado replica sale because nasty gentleman involving Japan is deemed one of several entire world market leaders throughout technological innovation along with invention.

There should be a few wrist watches that is going to both women of all ages and gentlemen could wear, nevertheless gals watches ordinarily have more design and style components this produce that they exceptional for females. These styles of gold perspective collections are often sorted by means of brand, so they help you produce a amount comparison plus styles pertaining to common collections involving girl's wrist watches. Women design and style timepieces can certainly be electronic electric, analog, or a wide selection of the not one but replica gucci handbags two. The design centers on replica Hermes Birkin 30 handbags each one of the watch elements including the deal cheap replica handbags by using and strap, which 's the reason some of your digital wrist watches can turn to be extremely female. At times the face replica Rolex watches area appeals to extra focus by using many finding unusual kinds or turn models. Several of the women design watches exceed the design and possibly restricting quite Replica Watches UK a few features.

Very good post, thank you. I am surprised to find your website. I like reading such profound information, actually thanks to resume services review online company I know a lot of useful tips about job search, resume writing, etc.

I like this a lot. Thank you for sharing. I'm always looking for upcycles like this. In the end, you don't know it was a shipping pallet to begin with!
T20 cricket world cup 2016 Groups List
ICC World Cup 2016 WC Live

Thanks for the share loved reading the article, please do share more like this wiht us .
whatsapp baixar
baixar whatsapp
baixar whatsapp gratis

This was actually what i was looking for, and i am glad to came here! Thank you very much

Post a Comment


Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More