advertisement

Tuesday, January 29, 2013

Two Cases Of Interest For The Aurora Theater Shooting: Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California (1976) & Jablonski v. U.S. (1983)

Are mental health workers supposed to help their clients,
or do they have a duty to protect the public from harm?
Dr. Lynne Fenton, the Aurora theater shooter's former psychiatrist, and the University of Colorado Hospital are facing several lawsuits from victims and victims' families. I wrote about the challenges facing the plaintiffs' attorneys in a blog post here. Assuming the attorneys are able to convince the court to order Dr. Fenton to release the shooter's records, there are two key legal cases that will play a part in the success or the failure of the lawsuits.

Tatiana Tarasoff
First, is Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California (1976). In this case, a UC-Berkeley student stalked, stabbed, and killed Tatiana Tarasoff, another student of the University. The murderer, who ended up getting off scott-free because of a technicality, had been treated for mental illness at the university's hospital. His treating psychologists failed to warn Ms. Tarasoff of the danger she was in. In 1974, the California Supreme Court ruled the university had a duty to warn her.

Two years later, the case made its way back to the California Supreme Court. At that time, the Court clarified its first ruling, and they found the university actually had a duty to protect Ms. Tarasoff. In the discharge of that duty, they stated the hospital should have notified the potential victim, called the police, and taken whatever steps that were "reasonably necessary under the circumstances." They further clarified that the university had a duty to break the killer's confidentiality in order to protect the potential victim. The most famous quote from this decision is, "The protective privilege ends where the public peril begins."

Prosenjit Poddar, Ms. Tarasoff's killer
One of the keys in the Tarasoff ruling was that the risk of violence must be such that the intended victim is in "foreseeable danger." More on that later.

The second case is Jablonski v. U.S. In this case, a man with a severe personality disorder and a history of rape and violence killed his girlfriend. The daughter of the girlfriend sued a hospital that failed to involuntarily hospitalize the man several weeks before the killing because they did not gather adequate information about him prior to making the decision to release him. The suit alleged the hospital also failed to warn the intended victim.

In this case, the trial court ruled the hospital was negligent for both above-mentioned reasons. The court ruled the hospital had an absolute duty to warn the girlfriend she was in foreseeable danger. On appeal, the Appeals Court affirmed the lower court's decision.

So, how do these cases relate to the lawsuits against Dr. Fenton? The Tarasoff decision would dictate that Dr. Fenton had a duty to protect potential victims from the shooter. Plaintiff's attorneys could argue she should have called the Aurora police and done more to escalate her concerns through the University of Colorado's emergency management system. She also could have had him involuntarily committed when campus police asked her if the shooter needed that level of care about a month before the shooting.

The tricky aspect with Tarasoff is that it is a California Supreme Court decision. Thus, it does not necessarily hold for different states. A defense attorney could argue there is no duty to protect spelled out in Colorado law the way it is in California. That is where the Jablonski decision becomes important. This was a decision through the U.S. Court of Appeals. Although it did not establish the duty to protect on the Federal level, it certainly established the duty to warn. And, the duty to protect, as it is described in the Tarasoff decision, has now become the standard of practice to which psychologists and psychiatrists are held, regardless of what state they work in.

The risk of harm is not always as foreseeable to
mental health workers as it is to this woman.
One final note: The attorneys who are suing Dr. Fenton have case law on their side, but they must prove one very important aspect regarding her treatment of the shooter--they must demonstrate Dr. Fenton knew, or should have known, there was "foreseeable danger." This will be a difficult task. First, most people who experience homicidal or suicidal thoughts never act on those thoughts. Plus, many patients will never tell their doctors about their homicidal thinking. Dr. Fenton will have had to have known about the shooter's homicidal ideation and believed it to be imminent enough that there was a duty to protect the public. Plus, she would have needed to know he had a specific plan against a person or a group of people (like a group of moviegoers).

Thanks for reading-- Max Wachtel, Ph.D.
www.CherryCreekPsychology.com
www.Facebook.com/drmaxwachtel
www.Twitter.com/mwachtel

302 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 302 of 302   Newer›   Newest»

This is really very nice blog and so informative, It give us lots of interest and pleasure.
DominoBet
Agen Poker
Domino99

Nice post, Thanks a lot of for share the informative and useful blog.
DominoQQ
Domino99
Daftar BandarQ

This is very educating post, thanks for sharing with us.
Tips Menang AduQ
Tips Bermain AduQ

It was really a great information thanks for sharing.
Daftar BandarQ
Domino99
DominoQQ

There are those Garnorax Erfahrungen who have used another brands of male enhancement pills and gotten zero or perhaps negative results out of them, and we cannot afford to dismiss either Garnorax Tabletten these points of view casually. So in the, while others don't. See more: http://www.wellnessfeiten.de/garnorax-erfahrungen/

There are those Garnorax Erfahrungen who have used another brands of male enhancement pills and gotten zero or perhaps negative results out of them, and we cannot afford to dismiss either Garnorax Tabletten these points of view casually. So in the, while others don't. See more: http://www.wellnessfeiten.de/garnorax-erfahrungen/

This is really very nice blog and so informative. Thanks a lot for sharing this article. BandarQ
The information which you people are given are really good, These look really great. BandarQQ
This is great, you are good, i like your post and i still waiting our next post Agen BandarQ
Thanks for giving me the useful information. I think I need it! BandarQ Online
Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic blog article.Thanks Again. Really Great. Situs BandarQ
Nice Post, and good Information for this site. Thanks for shared!! Daftar BandarQ

Bust Pro Fortunately, there is a bra available to fit almost any woman anywhere. There are even bras that are fashioned as "outer wear". Celebrities are among the more common members of society to tout such bold and daring styles. For the bold but slightly less daring, sheer and see through bras are a great option. Bras, whether made with or without under wires, are made from silk, cotton, Lycra, spandex and even flannel. Style has as much to do with what's available and "hot" as what a woman finds comfortable and supportive. The first formal "bras" were patented in the US in the mid 1800s, as tortuous corsets began to fall out of style with more comfort seeking women. Different Bra Types Many different bra types have been created since the early days of it's existence. No longer do women have to struggle to fit their upper body and chest into contraptions made of whalebone and steel (the common materials used to fashion early corsets). Rather, today's traditional bras are made of a variety of luxurious fabrics, meant to support, uplift, enhance and show off a woman's breasts (though you can still find some that minimize, which for many women is a bonus). See through and sheer bras, specialty bras, nursing and maternity bras, sports bras and even strapless and backless bras are all the rage in modern times. There is a bra available to fit any bust size and any individual style preference available. You can even have a bra custom made if you like. Though the corset is not completely banned from existence, new designs make wearing the contraption or similar ones much more feasible, and women no longer have to suffer pain and discomfort from wearing them. Interestingly, the bra did not gain popularity until about the 1920s during the time of the flappers when a flat chest was suddenly in, and women looked to minimize their bust line rather than enhance it. Among the first companies to jump on the bra making bandwagon during this time was the Maidenform Company, who created bra sizes in different bust size categories. As the breast minimizing trend of the early 20s faded and society entered the 30s, the idea of shape as acceptable became popular again, and Maidenform made an effort to make bras that would meet every woman's needs, including plus and full size bras. Warner's was among the first to create a cup sizing system that ranged from size A to size D, which are still standard sizes. At no time does a bra prove more useful than during exercise or during pregnancy/maternity.







http://www.dermayouth.org/bust-pro

I recently found many useful information in your website especially this blog page. UP Board 10th Result
UP Board 12th Result

Green juice has gained popularity for the list of health benefits associated with drinking it. It's a convenient way to ensure you're getting close to -- if not all of -- the USDA's daily recommended amounts of fruits and vegetables. Green juice can be quite tasty, and if you heed a few parameters, you may experience health benefits such as more energy, improved immunity and weight loss. The key is making sure you control the calories -- in addition to consuming your juice at the right time.
Energy
organifi gold
organifi green juice
patriot power greens
organifi green juice reviews
organifi green juice
nano towels

A of the a lot of Rapid Tone Shark Tank institution-like websites that house weight loss info are a bit stodgy and dry. This data, while for the foremost part credible, is plenteous, to the purpose where you start to feel like digesting it all may take months. See more: >>>> http://www.rapidtone-sharktank.com/

Rapid Tone Shark Tank Reviews pay some months deciding your own custom weight loss program, this sort of weight loss info may not be news you can use right now. Credible, but maybe TMI for your immediate wants. See more: >>>> http://www.rapidtone-sharktank.com/

Luna Trim Reviews It might appear obvious however typically we tend to simply opt for the incorrect weight loss merchandise for us. Some merchandise will specialise in the foods we have a tendency to eat, others will specialize in increasing our exercise routines. Some will ask us to count calories and some will provide us a suggested food arrange for every day. If you don't have the time to prepare the food, or the time to extend your exercise regime, opt for a product that suits your lifestyle whether or not it suggests that you will lose weight a little slower.
>>>>> Luna Trim

Weight loss supplements are any type of drugs that claims to Green Coffee Grano a private lose weight. These over the counter supplements are extraordinarily popular with people who are trying for some quite magical solution to the weight problems. Read more: http://www.testo-ultra.in/green-coffee-grano/

Your information is good and friendly this article very helpful for me.Thanks
Menang Ceme
Bandar Ceme
Ceme Online
Ceme 99
Qiu Ceme

Your information is good and friendly this article very helpful for me.Thanks
Menang Ceme
Bandar Ceme
Ceme Online
Ceme 99
Qiu Ceme

Your information is good and friendly this article very helpful for me.Thanks
Menang Ceme
Bandar Ceme
Ceme Online
Ceme 99
Qiu Ceme

Your information is good and friendly this article very helpful for me.Thanks
Menang Ceme
Bandar Ceme
Ceme Online
Ceme 99
Qiu Ceme

Your information is good and friendly this article very helpful for me.Thanks
Menang Ceme
Bandar Ceme
Ceme Online
Ceme 99
Qiu Ceme

Your information is good and friendly this article very helpful for me.Thanks
Menang Ceme
Bandar Ceme
Ceme Online
Ceme 99
Qiu Ceme

Your information is good and friendly this article very helpful for me.Thanks
Menang Ceme
Bandar Ceme
Ceme Online
Ceme 99
Qiu Ceme

Latest sports news headlines from India and world. Check out today's most recent & up-to-date news coverage, videos & photos at thesportsrumour.com
sports news

Latest news headlines from India in Hindi. Check out today’s most recent & up-to-date news coverage, videos & photos at dinacharya.in
latest news in hindi

Women! we have an amazing offer for you…
you can buy women’s clothes online in all over the world from Aixonne online store with extraordinary cheaper prices than any anywhere else.
Check our seasonal sales and new offers… you won’t leave our store unsatisfied!

suffering from HIV disease for over 4 years, i was hopeless until one of my friend directed me to a man called Dr Udi, she said he cures the sickness and also said he has also helped her friend, i never believed her but after alot of talk, i decided to give him a try, just few days ago i contacted him and he told me what to do which i did and he gave me a herbal cure which i took and then he told me to go for a test which i also did and when the result came out i was surprised to see that i am negative. I am proud to tell you the i am the most happiest person on earth I Give thanks to Dr Udi.. If you are having any problem and you need help, You can contact him with his email drudiherbalhome@gmail.com or Whatapp: +2348051243538.

suffering from HIV disease for over 4 years, i was hopeless until one of my friend directed me to a man called Dr Udi, she said he cures the sickness and also said he has also helped her friend, i never believed her but after alot of talk, i decided to give him a try, just few days ago i contacted him and he told me what to do which i did and he gave me a herbal cure which i took and then he told me to go for a test which i also did and when the result came out i was surprised to see that i am negative. I am proud to tell you the i am the most happiest person on earth I Give thanks to Dr Udi.. If you are having any problem and you need help, You can contact him with his email drudiherbalhome@gmail.com or Whatapp: +2348051243538.

hello everyone here i want to tell the whole world about DR AKIOYA herbal mixture product ...Dr AKIOYA penis enlargement herbal product in Africa.This is the only Male Penis Enlargement product has been used by men around the world like USA,CANADA,AUSTRALIA,BELGIUM,SWEDEN,GERMANY,UK,SINGAPORE,MALAYSIA AND SO MANY MORE supplement that has been PROVEN to-enlarge your penis – safely, quickly, and importantly – PERMANENTLY.Full DR AKIOYA Penis Enlargement product when used will Increase in penis length by 1-5 inches Increase in penis width by 20%helps in preventing Premature Ejaculation.Achieved longer, rock hard erections All gains in penis length and width are 100% permanent Full AKIOYA Penis Enlargement product is also:100% Herbal, 100% Safest with no side effect and its of two types I have the one for enlargement and for reduction and your advised to use it by message 100% Satisfaction and Money Back Guarantee. DR.AKIOYA, About my products i have herbal product and oil 100% Permanent Guaranteed resulting it on your body where you feel you want to reduce or enlarge which will help you to be strong and you get the desirable size you want-within 3-5 days and when you get your desirable size you are advised to stop using it and the results you gain will remain permanent We also do deliveries all over AFRICA, and worldwide so i would like to know first when do you need the product.for more information call or whatsapp Dr.AKIOYA +2348105257464 or call +2348105257464 email DrAkioya17spellhome@gmail.com
note DR AKIOYA also have herbal medicines to problems like
PENIS ENLARGEMENT
ERECTILE DYSFUNCTION
DIABETES type 1 and type 2
HERPES GENITAL WART
LOW SPERM COUNT
WEAK ERECTION
BREAST ENLARGEMENT
PROSTRATE CANCER
HIV/AIDS
SPELL OF ALL KINDS LIKE EX BACK,CANCEL DIVORCE,BREAK UP SPELL ,PREGNANCY SPELL,PROMOTION SPELL,JOB SPELL
ALS
HPV 123
PILE
ASTHMA
HEART FAILURE
PREMATURE EJACULATION
HEPATITIS A,B,C AND MANY MORE
THANKS

Hello everyone am JOHN PAUL from U.S.A, This is a testimony i want to make. I was HERPES positive for 8 years taking all sort of prescribed drugs from different Hospital and including my own doctor.
As i was reading online some 5 months ago i saw a testimony on cure of HERPES. At first i was really scared to give it a try. But Now as am telling you am very negative tested 4 times after applying the herbs as instructed by Dr Anonre. The cure is a pure herbs from Africa shipped to me through Delivery Service. My cure took about 4 days before getting to me. Dear brothers and sisters i shared this testimony to the public not to be happy alone because i know many people are out there that are in this situation i just over come but still believe there is no cure, please the cure is out and it works for me. If you are interested,email the researcher Dr AKIOYA using drakioya17spellhome@gmail.com, I will encourage every person who come across this mail to cure yourself if you are positive. You can add Dr AKIOYA up on Whatsapp +2348105257464

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 302 of 302   Newer› Newest»

Post a Comment

Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More