Monday, February 11, 2013

Emotional Distress From An Incorrectly Diagnosed STD: Molien v. Kaiser Foundation Hospital (1980)

What would you do if your spouse or partner came home from a doctor's appointment and told you he or she had syphilis?

If you are like most people, you would freak out.*

Your partner would get massive amounts of penicillin, and you would get a blood test to see if you had the sexually transmitted disease, too.

And then, the blame would begin. You would accuse your partner of cheating. Your partner would accuse you. Both of you would deny it. Neither of you would believe the other one. Anger, betrayal, disgust, rumors, fear of worse communicable diseases. Divorce or separation, maybe. It would be horrible, and it would likely ruin your relationship, at least for a substantial period of time.

Then, let's say, out of the blue, your partner gets a call from the doctor's office. They made a mistake--no one in your household had ever actually contracted syphilis.

Now what would you do?

If you were like the plaintiff in the landmark legal case Molien v. Kaiser Foundation Hospitals (1980), you would sue.

In this case, Mr. Molien's wife was mistakenly diagnosed and treated for syphilis. She accused Mr. Molien of having an extramarital affair, even though he tested negative for the disease. At the time of the lawsuit, the two had initiated divorce proceedings.

Mr. Molien sued the hospital for "negligently inflicted emotional distress" and "loss of consortium."

A quick aside into legal terminology: Negligently inflicted emotional distress is pretty much what it sounds like. The key here is that, prior to this case, courts had always found that emotional distress needed to be coupled with physical injury for there to be a "cause of action" (basically, something for which you could sue and potentially recover damages).

Can you sue the internet for
loss of consortium?
Loss of consortium refers to when a person misses out on whatever benefits of a family relationship are available to him/her because of the negligence of someone else. For example, a husband who can no longer spend quality time with his wife, depend on her for her share of running the household, have sex, etc. may sue for loss of consortium. Note: if the wife in this situation were to die because of the negligence of someone else, that is not loss of consortium. That is wrongful death.

Now back to the case: The trial court ruled that Mr. Molien did not have a cause of action (a valid reason to sue) on either of his allegations--there was no negligently inflicted emotional distress because he was not the patient and was not physically harmed, and there was no loss of consortium for similar reasons.

Mr. Molien appealed the case to the California Supreme Court, who agreed to hear it. In 1980, the Court issued its ruling in four main parts:

1. The alleged wrongdoing by the hospital was directed at both the wife and the husband in this case, even though the husband was not the patient.

2. The "risk of harm to the husband was reasonably foreseeable and, thus, [the hospital] owed the husband a duty to exercise due care in diagnosing the physical condition of his wife."

3. It did not matter that Mr. Molien did not suffer a physical injury. He still had a cause of action for "emotional distress."

4. There was also a cause of action for "loss of consortium."

This case is groundbreaking for two main reasons. First, it reinforced the notion that the spouse or partner of a patient could be considered a "direct victim" of medical negligence, even if that spouse/partner had not been the actual patient. Second, it set the precedent that a direct victim does not need to sustain a physical injury in order to be a victim of negligent infliction of emotional distress.

Thanks for reading-- Max Wachtel, Ph.D.

*This is anecdotal data, not supported by research. But, seriously, wouldn't you freak out?


Hence, nowadays every one of the popular celebrities on earth which includes needless to say the particular fake rolex uk glimmering gems are typical showing off Chanel perfume, that plays a part in the particular reputation and also glamour connected with Chanel's brand name, Amount 5, as an example. Thus, together with hundred years regarding knowledge inside marketing the brand name, hublot replica uk is not any automobile accident in which nowadays every person desires to very own Chanel perfume and also everything that a girl wants nowadays is always to pretty any section retailer in which right now there are sure to become cabinets filled up with Chanel perfume baby bottles regarding diverse measurements, fragrances and also styles. It's also advisable to study your chosen fake omega on the web since there are numerous lower price sites that may promote that you' jar regarding the girl perfume at under any section retailer. Simply you may recognize that the Cartier see might be a Low-cost and also it is possible to retain fake hublot a remedy in that case likely.

This simply means they can organize how, when, and where to study and most importantly the study skills they want to undertake. However it Grabmyessay online is the role of a guardian to instruct accordingly so that the individual undertakes the right study skills.

Various things do happen to students, therefore I always recommend to apply for essay writing assistance to prevent stress from happening in the first place.

To teach the knowledge in a best way is the good option to avoid the problem. There are several couples are loss their relationship due to the misunderstanding and the erectile weakness problem. Few of them are get cured from this health issue by using the generic viagra pills. So please talk with the health expert and overcome the loss of consortium

Great Post and thanks for sharing such a nice post. There are a few couples are misfortune their relationship because of the misconception and the erectile shortcoming issue. Maybe a couple of them are get
Buy Viagra at Cheap Price From GenericViargaSafe

As per the medical study results, it is possible to fight with the ED caused by emotional issues like stress and depression. The treatment of ED is possible through medical counseling or you can take Super P force. A magical solution that holds the two medicines ingredients and very effective.

To teach the information in a best way is the good option to avoid the problem. There are several couples are loss their relationship due to the misunderstanding and the impotence problems. Few of them are get cured from this problem by using the Online Penegra 100mg.

STD is sexually transmitted disease. I understand what a person must have gone through when his or her partner is not supporting and blaming each other. That becomes really painful. Going from two things at a time. Thank for sharing this touching post

buy generic viagra 100mg

SterJo Key Finder is a great way to find product keys because the program is easy to read, you can search through the results, and it supports a huge number of windows 7 home premium product key.

These kind of disease should be re-test immediately by the doctors, that's a big problem.
email login

I read this article and Thanks for sharing when all the important information is depend on you so the real fact is medication.
Online Generic Viagra

PPC has its very own brilliance to offer. From going ahead best of your clients' quests to focusing on a particular gathering of people, the ppc management company technique ought to be an essential piece of your promoting plan.

If you are looking for IVF treatment in hyderabad then SWCIC is the best hospital for IVF treatment

Assam Class 11 Textbook list is released in online mode. AHSEC Board Class 11 books, syllabus, question papers and study materials details are given below. Assam 11th Standard Assamese, Hindi, English, Mathematics, Physics, Biology, Chemistry,Assam 11th Book pdf ​Botany, Zoology, Political Science, Economics, Business Studies, Accountancy, and other subjects EBooks will be updates on the official website. Textbooks are a crucial one to the pursuing candidates. SCERT Assam Learning outcome books are download here. For more details regarding on Assam Higher Secondary first year syllabus, textbooks, blueprint, and model question papers kindly visit the official web portal.

Post a Comment


Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More