advertisement

Wednesday, April 3, 2013

The Death Penalty Is Cruel and Unusual Punishment for Juveniles: Roper v. Simmons (2005)


On September 9, 1993, Christopher Simmons and a friend bound Shirley Cook in duct tape and electrical cables, beat her, and threw her into a river from a bridge. The coroner for St. Louis County, Missouri, ruled her death a drowning.

The evidence against Mr. Simmons was overwhelming. He had clearly premeditated the attack and murder, had bragged about it later, and he confessed to the police. He went so far as to re-enact the attack and murder for the police. There was witness testimony against him as well. The jury had no option but to find him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

Mr. Simmons was then sentenced to death for first degree murder. In the sentencing phase of his court case, his defense attorneys failed to bring out extensive mitigating evidence of Mr. Simmons' horrific childhood history of abuse and drug and alcohol abuse. His history is well-documented by The International Justice Project. To summarize, his stepfather would beat him regularly, neglect him as a toddler, and feed him alcohol at ages as young as four in order to entertain the father's friends.

On appeal, Mr. Simmons argued he had ineffective counsel because this mitigating evidence was not brought to light. In fact, at least one juror who sentenced him to death could not understand why a person who was presented as being an upstanding citizen could snap and engage in such horrible behavior.

The trial court hearing the appeal did not agree with Mr. Simmons' argument, so it was sent to an Appeals Court. This is where the case gets really interesting.

Even though he was an adult at the time of his conviction and sentencing, Mr. Simmons was only 17 at the time of the murder. His new attorneys dropped the issue of ineffective assistance of counsel and focused on his age and his potential diagnosis of mental retardation. They argued the case all the way to the Missouri Supreme Court, which held that it would be considered cruel and unusual punishment (Eighth Amendment) to execute an individual who was mentally retarded. It would also be a violation of the Eighth Amendment to execute a juvenile under the age of 18 at the time of the offense.

The State of Missouri appealed this decision to the U.S. Supreme Court, who agreed to hear the case in 2004.

The State of Missouri argued that executing a 17 year-old is not an Eighth Amendment violation, due to the Court's decision in 1989 upholding death sentences for juveniles ages 16 or above (Stanford v. Kentucky). Complicating the state's case, however, was Atkins v. Virginia (2002), where the Court found executing someone who is mentally retarded to be unconstitutional.

After hearing oral arguments, the Court deliberated and issued a ruling in 2005. They upheld the Missouri Supreme Court's decision to set aside Mr. Simmons' death sentence. They cited statistics in their ruling indicating a majority of states had already outlawed death sentences for juveniles, and they noted Americans view juveniles as "categorically less culpable than the average criminal." The scientific basis for this ruling was explained as follows:

"(1) the lack of maturity and an underdeveloped sense of responsibility were found in youth more often than adults and were more understandable among the young;

"(2) juveniles were more vulnerable or susceptible to negative influences and outside pressures, including peet pressure; and

"(3) the character of a juvenile was not as well formed as that of an adult."

As a result of this case, Mr. Simmons' sentence was reduced from death to life in prison without parole. And, the U.S. Supreme Court created a new standard for the death penalty--it is now a violation of the Eighth Amendment to execute anyone who committed murder prior to the age of 18.

Thanks for reading-- Max Wachtel, Ph.D.
www.CherryCreekPsychology.com
www.Twitter.com/mwachtel
www.Facebook.com/drmaxwachtel
www.YouTube.com/drmaxwachtel

10 comments:

Your detailed blog is very good. Keep doing this work.
Bomb-mp3 UK proxy

If you had anticipation that these Swiss replica watches are not exact replicas of the originals,you are barking up the amiss tree.The craftsmen who accomplish these watches accord added absorption to replica watches uk ensure that the user of their Swiss replica watches get the best in craftsmanship.They see to it that the end user gets something that cannot be differentiated from the aboriginal Swiss watches.What are you cat-and-mouse for then? If you are gluttonous accurate amount for your money and at the aforementioned time wish to rolex replica backpack a appearance account on your hand,you charge to abrasion Swiss replica watches.If you are one of them who accept that just one acceptable affair is not enough,again go advanced and splurge your money in a amount of Swiss replica watches.You can be blow assured that there is annihilation that makes arch about-face added like the getting who wears one Swiss replica watches in the morning and addition in the evening.We plan ancillary by ancillary with the manufacturers to analyze the a lot of gucci replica exact adjustment to carbon anniversary style.You will get actually what you see in the picture.You can assurance us,for anniversary replica handbag,we are consistently try our best to agreement the cut,stitch,style,blush and material.All of these replica handbags can accordance you the Though replicas,they still advance a top superior akin like that of louis vuitton replica aboriginal Chanel artist bags.Assure that you boutique from a 18-carat online replica backpack abundance so that you get the best superior of Chanel replica accoutrements that you wish to allowance it to anyone special.

A good wardrobe the fact that fulfils wonderfully towards all clothes, ready for its freedom to combine utilizing chanel replica numerous dresses, together with actually for year or so. A important offer stands out as the structure they need, all their in good shape most of kinds of gear, irrespective of whether ringtones or simply rather dark brown ringtones, it is likely the fact that once you discover those sacks not shop for one other type, given that it's the the majority there has to be together with tag heuer Replica sale it all creates terrific coziness (the worth / superior ratio set in stabilize). At the same time, any tarpaulin utilizing which unfortunately those shopping bags are fashioned happen to be thoroughly water-resistant. It can be a model of sacks the fact that seduces together with brings notice, is particularly amazing together with beautiful and tend to be always appearing refreshed utilizing terrific layout together with envelops the whole works. The worth usually is approximately 100-320 euros, dependant upon the skin container version and then the point in time for hublot replica sale the season wherein people shop for, however , it can be a superior financial commitment whatever your expense. Every last spring/summer any important comfort real estate will let go an item different, an item psyched together with different. Mutually of most rolex replica sale economical North american comfort types, Train isn't an omission. A short time ago Train revealed any Parker set demonstrating a different beauty when the sacks have grown ladylike together with gynaecoid. Consumers at one time longines replica when compared to any Parker sacks utilizing human beings dressed up meant for school regarding Easter Tuesday - posh together with amazing utilizing a touch of quiet glamour.

I want to share any applications example baixar snapchat, google play and play store. Snapchat is app which everybody like, it's chat app. Baixar google play and play store are two applications of google. It allows you download applications and games which you like. Please, baixar play store to mobile to experience

If you had anticipation that these Swiss replica watches are not exact replicas of the originals,you are barking up the amiss tree. here also we providing the best credit card processing services

Thank your site! information your share is useful to me!

games for kids | slither.io | wings.io | happy wheels | abcya

which was 4 curved before reminiscent of, handbag replica each of floral carved (I found a Florence architectural elements in many of the church). All of sculpture, is contrasted to add to the brightness of its visual impact. Internal 47 mm manual-winding movement with a three-day power reserve Rolex Daytona in the case, the P.3000, is. Only 99 are generated for Replica Watches .If you want to choosing a Replica handbags , Replica watches UK allows you to send a powerful message style.

Post a Comment

Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More